At what age should parents have 'the talk' with their kids?

A new study suggests that most parents wait far too long to discuss sex with their children. Hoda Kotb and Kathie Lee Gifford discussed the issue on TODAY. Vote and share your thoughts.

Results with 5 short comments
Total of 527 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

16.5%
Between ages 5 to 6. They're ready to start learning the basics at these ages.
87 votes
23%
By age 8. That's when kids start getting really curious.
121 votes
60.5%
Between ages 9-11. They really don't need to know and can't fully understand it before then.
319 votes
Display Comments:
Between ages 5 to 6. They're ready to start learning the basics at these ages.

I would be surprised if my children didn't ask a sex related question by the age of 5. Kids naturally want to know how they got here.

     - 1:14 pm EST on Wed Dec 9, 2009
    Between ages 9-11. They really don't need to know and can't fully understand it before then.

    I had the talk to my daughter before she started middle school(6th gr.) . Now she is in 8th gr. and i still have to remind of the talk.

       - pam3467
       - 2:22 pm EST on Wed Dec 9, 2009
      Between ages 9-11. They really don't need to know and can't fully understand it before then.

      I think kids are ready to hear certain things at certain times. Parents can tell when there kids are ready to hear certain things.

         - jamib
         - 7:55 pm EST on Thu Dec 10, 2009
        Between ages 9-11. They really don't need to know and can't fully understand it before then.

        My daughter ask me quesions regarding sex, then I give her an age approiate answer for a 10 year old girl. I make her fill comfortable

           - 2:19 pm EST on Fri Dec 11, 2009
          Between ages 5 to 6. They're ready to start learning the basics at these ages.

          I'd had parts of The Talk with each of my kids before 4. It doesn't have to be all at once - just explain things as they come up.

             - 11:58 am EST on Fri Jan 15, 2010

            "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

            advertisement

            Discuss this post

            I don't think you "a" single talk. It should be ongoing and age appropriate. Little by little and you expand as they grow. We started at around 4 with the basic differences in gender, she is 6 now, and we talk about how bodies change when you become a teenager. We have opened the door to the topic, so we don't feel uncomfortable about something so personal.

            • 2 votes
            Reply#1 - Thu Dec 10, 2009 7:42 AM EST

            I was going to say the same thing! We did the same with our kids. Good post!

              #1.1 - Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:46 AM EST

              Hear, hear. We've taught our son and daughter (5 and 8, respectively) a lot about anatomy, like where to knee a would-be abductor (and where not to knee Dad), the basics of reproduction, menstruation, and a few other details. We just explain things as they come up, as honestly and completely as they can handle. They're inquisitive, and accepting of information they may not fully understand. But yes - the main point is that "the talk" is dozens of little talks, starting WAY before the onset of sexual maturity. I want my kids to be safe, protected, to value sex as something special to be saved for special people, and I want them to be good at it. By the time they need the information, they'll have it. I'm delighted that I haven't yet seen the prudishness and body-shame I was sure I'd find on this board.

                #1.2 - Fri Jan 15, 2010 12:03 PM EST
                Reply

                I agree with Mary-- you can not just have THE talk. It needs to be an ongoing open and honest relationship right form birth. a penis is a penis and a vagina is a vagina- it is not a pocket, a monkey, a picklle, or a turtle. Stop giving these pet names! You do not have to explain the full concept of reproduction at 5 years of age but stop making up cutsey the stork brought you here stories. Kids are curious not stupid. Answer their questions simplistically but honestly. If they are asking they are ready to hear an answer!

                • 1 vote
                Reply#2 - Fri Dec 11, 2009 11:00 AM EST

                YES!!!!! I just re-watched the movie "Knocked Up," and noticed that a recurring theme is how effortlessly the adults lie to the kids. I was raised with some information and a lot of (non-cutesy) euphemisms. My kids are being raised with facts, real names, and a complete lack of shame. I can't imagine wanting to do it any other way.

                  #2.1 - Fri Jan 15, 2010 12:06 PM EST
                  Reply

                  The lack of discussion shows just how uncomfortable peope are with this subject. I also believe "THE TALK" should be ongoing & age appropriate. Peope need to realize that their children are going to hear it somewhere. It needs to be from loving parents that want their children to hear the truth. Please don't wait until Megan is pregnant or Jhn's girlfriend is pregnant before having this important discussion. Your kids can either learn from you or learn it from their friends & experiences. Kids should be taught about the changes their body is going through & how they should control their hormones & wait until they are in a permanent relationship before giving it up. The moral fabric of this country has stooped to levels that place sex on a level with paying a board game.

                  • 2 votes
                  Reply#3 - Sun Dec 13, 2009 5:33 AM EST

                  If one doesn't have ongoing talks about sex and all it involves with one's children, one may end up raising one's grandchildren. Then, one may end up raising one's great-grandchildren.

                  My comment is no joke. It happened in my family. Makes it really easy to see that when grandparent's raise their grandchildren, they make the same mistakes. Luckily, I was old enough to step in with my second cousin and give her the talk.

                  I find it ironic when what comes around goes around with the 'religious' parents that don't bother to teach their children about sex and they end up with pregnant teenagers.

                    Reply#4 - Tue Dec 15, 2009 4:16 PM EST

                    A lot of times the religious parents preach abstinence, and we know how well that works, don't we?

                    Abstinence is a fine concept, but you need to be realistic.

                    • 1 vote
                    #4.1 - Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:50 AM EST

                    I agree. Abstinence is a part of sexuality, but to "teach" it and nothing else is foolhardy. I say "teach" in quotes, because - come on - it's not teaching anything just to say "don't do it." Teaching is imparting knowledge - facts - and our kids deserve as many facts as we can give them. They're going to do what they're going to do. Isn't it better that they're prepared for situations that may come up someday?

                      #4.2 - Fri Jan 15, 2010 12:10 PM EST
                      Reply

                      My folks never had 'the talk' with me. Or any of my siblings either. Later, in college, the conversation went that way, and I asked why 'the talk' never occured. She told me it was because she knew us well enough to know that we would never get at it as teenagers (mostly because of religious convictions)...furthermore she said, and I quote, "I figured it out, and you're no dummy, I knew you could figure it out too."

                        Reply#5 - Sat Feb 13, 2010 7:07 PM EST

                        If we are suppose to take the topic of talking with our kids about sex serioulsy, then how about you guys not making such a joke about it while you discuss it.

                        • 1 vote
                        Reply#6 - Thu Mar 25, 2010 11:48 AM EDT

                        My youngest daughter will be 12 in May and she lives with her dad and has 2 step sisters that are 1 and 2 yrs older then her. When she came to see me she asked me about period's because they haven't explained it to her yet and she could start at any age now. She also asked about sex cuz some of the kids in school where talking about it. So I just told her what she wanted to know not x rated of course but I can't belive her father hasn't talked with her about any of this. She lives in big city so I just went on and talked about strangers and how easy it is to be abducted, she had no idea. Thats scary....Anyway I think these days you need to start the talk around 10. It's sad that kids are getting into sex at such an early age these days but better to have them safe then for them to end up pregnant or some kind of disease

                          Reply#7 - Thu Mar 25, 2010 11:49 AM EDT

                          I think that Amber deserves an apology for her segment being ruined by the immature antics of the hosts and surprise guest Jimmy Fallon. I was genuinely interested in the segment and got nothing out of it because of them. I hope Amber is invited to a show that can handle the segment with more professionalism. I don't know why I ever expect more from the Today Show. I need to learn to change the channel!

                            Reply#8 - Thu Mar 25, 2010 11:59 AM EDT

                            A u can see I also had the same comment earlier Don't know why Kathie Lee always has to turn the show into all about her, I too felt bad for Amber Lisa gs

                              #8.1 - Thu Mar 25, 2010 4:42 PM EDT
                              Reply

                              The problem with statistics is that they can be misleading. One of the statistics said that 3 out of 10 women will become pregnant before the age of 20 but I have dozens of friends that did not get pregnant before 20. That statistic would only be accurate in some situations. The statistics could actually have a negative impact by convincing teens that by a certain age they should have sex. Another statistic shared on the show said that the majority of teens will have sex before they graduate. That statistic does not tell you how many teens they actually polled. They may have asked a couple of hundred or even a couple of thousand and then applied that information to the millions of kids that are out there. And the number of kids having sex varies from study to study. So, while it is very important to talk to kids about sex, don't use statistics as a guideline! And while talking to kids about sex it's also important to talk about abstinence. Abstinence is the only method that has a 100% guarantee against STDs and pregnancy.

                                Reply#9 - Thu Mar 25, 2010 1:13 PM EDT

                                So as a single mother of a 10 and 8 year old I was looking forward to watch this part of the show regarding this important topic. I really love getting invaluable advice on this topic and how to be able to reach out to my kids. I was very dissapointed by the lack of professionalism both Kathie Lee and Hoda presented while discussing the issue with the expert and author, Amber Madison, not only was the presentation of the information and book horrible, Jimmy Fallon came in and intererupted the discussion. Not only did Ms. Madison seem annoyed but I think a lot of viewers were too, beginning with me. I was looking forward to getting information and felt that the lack of maturity and information was ill-presented. I understand trying to be light hearted and funny but this is an important topic that should be taken seriously and discussed in a serious matter. There is so much sexual exploitation, diseases, and technology moving at the speed of light I like to plug in to as much information as I can. This is a serious topic! The Jimmy Fallon jokes and the ladies laughing and interuppting the guest was so rude! I know she wasn't there to teach the viewers but promote her book but living on one budget doesn't allow me to go out and buy whatever I want. They need to respect the guests and the viewers more and a little maturity on their part would't hurt. One of the reasons I will not watch the show anymore. Grow up KLG and Hoda!!! Didn't anyone else feel this way?

                                Signed,

                                So Annoyed I Needed to Leave A Comment

                                • 1 vote
                                Reply#10 - Thu Mar 25, 2010 2:57 PM EDT

                                totally agree

                                  Reply#11 - Thu Mar 25, 2010 4:53 PM EDT
                                  You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                  As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.