Are moms who leave their families judged more harshly than dads who do the same?

Live Poll

Are moms who leave their families judged more harshly than dads who do the same?

View Results
  • 94791
    Yes. There is a definite double standard when it comes to parents who abandon their families.
    80%
  • 94792
    No. Society is just as unforgiving of deadbeat dads as it is of runaway moms.
    10%
  • 94793
    It depends on the circumstances.
    9%
  • 94794
    I’m not sure. I'll explain my thoughts in the comments.
    1%

VoteTotal Votes: 1043

Ohio mom Tiffany Tehan, who spurred a nationwide search when she disappeared in April -- leaving behind her husband and 1-year-old daughter -- explained that she wanted to “start a new life” when she was found in Miami with another man. Has she been judged more harshly than a man who left his family for another woman would be? Share your thoughts with other readers.

Results with 8 short comments
Total of 1,043 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

80%
Yes. There is a definite double standard when it comes to parents who abandon their families.
834 votes
10%
No. Society is just as unforgiving of deadbeat dads as it is of runaway moms.
104 votes
8.9%
It depends on the circumstances.
93 votes
1.2%
I’m not sure. I'll explain my thoughts in the comments.
12 votes
Display Comments:
I’m not sure. I'll explain my thoughts in the comments.

I think they're both just about equally looked down upon, but runaway moms have a bigger shock value. We're surprised & don't expect it.

  • 1 vote
 - 12:25 pm EDT on Mon Apr 26, 2010
It depends on the circumstances.

Mothers give birth to their children and one would think have a closer bond than that of fathers. I didn't carry her in my body for 9 month

     - 4:14 pm EDT on Mon Apr 26, 2010
    Yes. There is a definite double standard when it comes to parents who abandon their families.

    WOmen "hardwired" to be connected to their children? Just when you think we'd gone beyond such stupidity! Hogwash.

       - JSayler
       - 9:08 pm EDT on Mon Apr 26, 2010
      I’m not sure. I'll explain my thoughts in the comments.

      I think that we are more used to Fathers abandoning the family then Mothers, therefore it resonates more.

         - robync
         - 10:48 am EDT on Wed Apr 28, 2010
        Yes. There is a definite double standard when it comes to parents who abandon their families.

        There has always been a dbl standard in this. A mom leaves- she's horrible. A dad leave's he's a dead beat but no one gives a 2nd glance.

           - 10:08 pm EDT on Wed Apr 28, 2010
          Yes. There is a definite double standard when it comes to parents who abandon their families.

          Depending on the circumstances...the major issue here is...how will the children develop without experiencing trust issues???

             - 11:17 pm EDT on Wed Apr 28, 2010
            I’m not sure. I'll explain my thoughts in the comments.

            Bothe the husband/father and the wife/mother should get a life and own up to the absolute responsibilities they face daily.

               - 9:39 pm EDT on Fri Apr 30, 2010
              Yes. There is a definite double standard when it comes to parents who abandon their families.

              Some parents are doing their kids a favor by leaving them with competant and loving caregivers. Dads don't get the backlash that moms do.

                 - 5:13 pm EDT on Thu May 20, 2010

                "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

                Discuss this post

                I don't agree with her leaving her family, but this sort of thing happens everyday, why is this story making big news? So she wants another life. If anyone should pay for this it should be the people who wanted to find her. There has to be a reason why she wanted to leave with this guy. Let them be.

                • 1 vote
                Reply#1 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 10:19 AM EDT

                This is exactly what I think also. This happens everyday with MEN and WOMEN leaving their babies. Why is this story a big deal on the news???? She had to been seeing this guy before they ran away and no body knew? Give me a break!!

                  #1.1 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 10:54 AM EDT

                  Another Life.... Being a mother and step-mother myself, I am living with the ramifications of what happens when the "birth mother" leaves her child. Several years ago, my husband and I were granted full custody of his daughter. Even though my step-daughter is available to see her mother every other weekend and holidays, her mother is never around. My step-daughter is constantly dissapointed by false promises but still protects and defends her mother's actions any chance she gets. I think it is a disgrace that any parent, male or female, has the ability to birth these children, but does not feel any committment to raise them. They are very comfortable letting someone else do the job.

                    #1.2 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 1:39 PM EDT

                    I think this story made the news because she made it appear to be a disappearance with foul play. If the husband had had a clue of the truth prior to her disappearance, then this would have, indeed, been like what happens everyday in America and not newsworthy. Her biggest mistake is that people were concerned foul play was involved, thus a nationwide search.

                    People have very lopsided expectations of mothers and fathers anyway. Because mothers are elevated so highly in value over fathers-compare father's day and mother's day celebrations- mother's are judged more harshly. The higher the high in esteem, the lower the lows when irresponsibility occurs. Sounds like a case of wanting the cake and eating it, too. Women are seen as victims more often when they commit irresponsible actions; men don't get that luxury. How about somebody asking "Do men get more severe consequences in court (criminal and/or family court) than women convicted of the same charges?" The point, there are clearly gender biases in both directions in our society, yet only the perceived injustices against women get the PC news questions like the one we are addressing today.

                      #1.3 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 4:13 PM EDT
                      Reply

                      Yes, they are judged more harshly, but they should be.  The reason for this is that, on the flip side, in many states men don't have nearly the same rights in custody cases as women.

                        Reply#2 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 10:19 AM EDT

                        Yes, there is a double standard but there shouldn't be. Both men and women should be judged very harshly if they abandon their children, biological or adopted. I think every deadbeat parent should have their driver's license and passport revoked and have their picture and info on a deadbeat parent website like some canadian provinces do in order to shame these repulsive "humans".

                        Speaking specifically about this case, regardless of her relationship with her husband, disappearing like that was incredibly selfish and irresponsible so it's probably for the best that she is out of her child's life. The child is better off without such a sad excuse for a mother. Hopefully (and probably) her "new man" will do the same to her before long.

                          Reply#3 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 10:48 AM EDT

                          I don't think anyone needs to judge anyone, when laws have not been broken. It would be a different story if she had not left her child with the baby's father in the family home, in other words in the safest possible environment. We are always hearing of stories when women pack up the kids to run off with men, men who might be sex offenders or worse, or even mothers who kill their children if they are inconvenient. She did none of these things and should not be held up to be judged by strangers. Justice is for criminal acts...not personal ones, no matter if we agree or disagree about the acts, in my opinion.

                          • 1 vote
                          Reply#4 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 11:12 AM EDT

                          I am a Mother of 4 and would never leave my children, but as for someone who has decided that it is easier to start a new life with someone else, LEAVE HER ALONE! This woman obviously thought it was easier for her to leave without saying anything (has anyone looked into her life with her husband). Everyone needs to stop pointing fingers and start looking into our own backyards.

                            Reply#5 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 11:19 AM EDT

                            If she was so unhappy in her marriage, there is a little thing called divorce. I'm sorry there is no need to cheat on your spouse, that is cheating on your family!! As for her taking off like that with this so called "man". Sorry, no real "man" would have anything to do with a married woman, let alone a married woman with a small baby. Nor would he allow her to leave the small child. What does that say for the man. But back to her. Her leaving her child, will probably cause abandonment issue for this child later in life. Placing fear in her personal family and friends lives, just shows how selfish and immature this woman really is. The money and resources that where wasted on trying to find her. Please don't tell me oh, we don't know what she has been through, she could have been abused. There are shelters, she could turn to, restraining orders to have ordered, and if she was so in fear of her life, she surely would not have left her child!! This was just a case of woman who realized she made a mistake and was shallow and didn't know how to get out of it. So she ran!!

                              Reply#6 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 12:01 PM EDT

                              I agree with crisd. I think those of you that are saying, "what's the big deal?" need to take a look at yourselves. If you can't see that this is wrong you need help. People leave each other every day, BUT....be considerate of all involved and let them know that you are safe. Leave a note. Make a phone call. Something! For those of you that want to blame the family for looking, what is wrong with you?! Crazy things happen every day. How would you feel if someone had taken you, kidnapped you, abused you, etc. and found out that your family didn't even try to look for you? Situations like this cause officials to not take real situations seriously. She and this man should be responsible for every dime they caused from their immature and irresponsible behavior. There is always another solution!

                                Reply#7 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 2:17 PM EDT

                                I so agree with you!! And, as a mother myself, I just can't comprehend what she did. I can understand leaving your husband, but not ever leaving your child. She had options...instead she chose to ruin & devastate the lives of the people that love her. I feel sorry for her little girl...

                                  #7.1 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 6:53 PM EDT
                                  Reply

                                  I love the fact that there is so many concerned parents... step-parents around that agree with me. The fact that some people say "not to judge" or "leave her be" tells me that that either one, are not parents themselves, or 2, are not tax paying citizens. You realize when one child becomes a warden of the state, you and me, as tax paying, working class citizens, pay for their child reiring... Just a thought to keep in mind. I know this world is not all about money, but someone gotta pay for this bad behvior, or the lack their of....

                                    Reply#8 - Mon Apr 26, 2010 7:41 PM EDT

                                    there has always been a double standard in this. a dad leaves & he's a dead beat but no one give him a second glance. a mother leave's and FORGET IT. she's a lost soul; a horrible person because she never formed the 'mother' bond. we need to start re-thinking how mom's are 'supposed' to act. i love my daughter, but there are some moms out there who can't understand that i need my own time and that i DONT always put my daughter's need before mine. i am in the mind that you don't deny yourself what you feel the same way you don't deny your kid's feelings. you were an individual BEFORE you had kids, you should be able to be one AFTER them. what i don't agree with is completely disregarding a child 's WELFARE. this is VERY different from the difference between your kid being sick & you cannot do girls night but you still go from your kid wanting to watch cartoons & you want to read & you end up reading. moms- get over yourself and the attitude of 'now-that-i-have-kids-i-will-only-do-for-them-first-ALWAYS'. ditching is ditching, no matter who does it and the repercussion should measure the same for both parties.

                                      Reply#9 - Wed Apr 28, 2010 10:19 PM EDT

                                      My grandkids are being raised by their dad with input from both sets of grandparents. The nicest thing their mom has ever done for them was stepping aside; she's an increasingly dangerous addict. In the case of Tehan and her married man; the way that they left showed a thoughtlessness, selfishness and immaturity that proves what kind of influence they'd have been on her baby. That said -> Abandoning a child leaves serious scars unless the situation is carefully handled.

                                        Reply#10 - Thu May 20, 2010 5:19 PM EDT
                                        You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                        As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.