Top three parenting mistakes with tweens and teens

Amy McCready

By Amy McCready, Positive Parenting Solutions founder and TODAY Moms contributor

Parents want to have close relationships with their children, but many wonder if that’s even possible as their once sweet, loving, cuddly child enters adolescence.  Suddenly, your son is more interested in peers than spending time with the family, your daughter may be showing more rebellious behavior, and now, instead of being the one they turn to for advice, you don’t know a thing!

While scary for parents, the normal individualization process during the tween and teen years doesn’t have to involve power struggles and hard feelings if parents avoid these three common parenting mistakes:


1.  Too much "ordering, correcting & directing”:  Yes, you are still the parent, but take a close look at how often you bark orders at your kids.  No one wants to be bossed around and constant "ordering, correcting and directing" is sure to backfire.  In fact, it’s a guaranteed way to get your tween or teen to shut down or rebel.  Parents wouldn't order, correct and direct co-workers or friends, and it’s an ineffective communication style for our kids as well. 

Instead, use a calm voice and make respectful and reasonable requests.  Ask yourself the question… “How would I feel if someone made this same request of me?”  Tweens and teens must be held accountable for their behavior and that can be done in a way that fosters a mutually respectful relationship and empowers kids to learn from their choices. 

Instead of “ordering” – try “inviting cooperation”… “I’m slammed with work this evening.  Anything you can do to help with the dinner clean up would really make a difference for me tonight.”  Most of the time  – the teen will lend a hand!

Instead of “directing” – “You need to get that project finished!”  Try, “What are your plans for your finishing your project this week?”  It allows your teen to think it through and demonstrates that you have faith that she has a plan in place.  If not, it allows her to save face as she quickly develops one! And, this is ok since you are allowing her to figure it out on her own.

2.  Exerting too much control:  Part of the normal development process for teens is to separate from us – but that invokes fear in most parents and they respond by “clamping down.”  Instead of respecting the child’s need for greater autonomy, parents attempt to exert more control, which escalates power struggles.

Recognize your teen’s growing need for power and autonomy.  Instead of “clamping down,” look for opportunities to give your teen MORE responsibility and decision making opportunities. 

Be reasonable with curfews and privileges.  Demonstrate faith in your teen by giving a little more rope – but within your comfort zone.  Be very clear about the responsibilities that accompany his or her privileges and be sure to reveal consequences in advance.  That way your child will be perfectly clear about what will happen if he or she decides to violate curfew for instance.  As the late parenting educator and author, H. Stephen Glenn said, “Children need enough rope to get rope burn, but not enough to hang themselves.”

Involve your teen in family decisions and problem solving as appropriate.  If the chores aren’t getting done, sit down and brainstorm solutions to solve the problem and agree on a plan you all feel good about.  Be clear about the consequences if the plan isn’t followed and have him repeat the plan and the possible consequences back to you to ensure that you’re all on the same page.

3.  Not being ON their team.  Most teens feel that their parents are against them – not with them.  When parents order, direct and correct too much, interrogate them about every little thing, or try to exert too much control – it invites power struggles and reinforces the feeling that we’re against them.  When teens feel parents are ON their team, they are more likely to communicate honestly and openly and may actually want to spend time with the family!

Show that you’re ON their team by getting into their world.  Spend one-on-one time with them – on a daily basis – doing what THEY like to do.  Parents often perceive that teens don’t want to spend time with parents – but they do!  Taking 10 minutes, one or two times a day to talk, hang out, download music - or whatever your teen enjoys - increases your emotional connection and works wonders in keeping lines of communication open.  It reinforces that you are "on her team" - not against her.

As our children grow, their needs change and the interaction between parent and child needs to change as well.  We must allow our teens to spread their wings by giving them autonomy and power, while still respecting and obeying our rules.  It’s a bittersweet fact of life that if we do our job well, our kids should be able to grow up and away from us.  As parenting author Alfie Kohn wrote, “The way kids learn to make good decisions is by making decisions, not by following directions.”

Amy McCready is the founder of Positive Parenting Solutions and mom to two boys, ages 12 and 14. Positive Parenting Solutions teaches parents of toddlers to teens how to correct misbehaviors permanently without nagging, reminding or yelling. For free discipline training resources, visit: www.PositiveParentingSolutions.com

"Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

Discuss this post

I'm pretty sure that STEALING all of your child's money from "their" bank account and "their "College Fund is on that list too! That's what my daughter's unstable so-called father did to me! These top 3 things he did perfectly along with his disgusting second wife Tami! They both terrorized her for years. Now that she's 19 years old she never see either of them and spends all her time with the only parent that supported her and was ALWAYS in her corner... MOM! She's an honor roll student and a National Honor Society Student as well. She's currently in college and I'm was the only one who helped her get there! To all you parents out there...do not do this to your kids - it destroys them! Take it from me...and when they get old enough to make their own decisions - they will - and you will not be in their lives anymore - like my her DEADBEAT dad - Jon!

  • 1 vote
Reply#1 - Wed Oct 13, 2010 1:37 PM EDT

Andrea, while I sympathize with your situation, this is not the place to air your grievances. I would suggest you get some counseling, get outside and enjoy the beautiful world and try to find some peace. Yes what deadbeat did is heinous and wrong, but its done, and it is only poison in your system. Let it go - you will be so much happier if you do. Take it from one who knows....

  • 6 votes
#1.1 - Wed Oct 13, 2010 4:29 PM EDT

Let the hate keep you warm on cold nights.

    #1.2 - Thu Oct 14, 2010 7:20 PM EDT
    Reply

    This column is true to reality.  As a parent and grandparent of 13 and a professional who's worked with kids every year since 1968, I can say this is some of the best advice I've seen.  Follow it, and your family will be a source of great satisfaction to all members. 

    • 1 vote
    Reply#2 - Wed Oct 13, 2010 5:41 PM EDT

    Kids who are chronic victims of bullies typically have parents who they

    perceive as not being on their side.   It is one thing to face a bully if you know

    your parents are with you.   It is another to face a bully when you know your parents

    are going to punish you for starting a fight if you stand up to them.

     

    So much for teaching that "Christian Turn the Other Cheek" nonsense.

     

      Reply#3 - Thu Oct 14, 2010 7:19 PM EDT

      i disagree. I think you need firm rules before they reach this age so you wont have to worry about phrasing things. "anything you can do to help" is silly--ask them for what you need specifically, then everyone knows what is expected and they are happy they can meet expectations.

      I think parents need to be parents--not negotiators. these are tough years, but you can get through them with great kids and a great relationship. Here are my tips: Stay up until they get home at night and be available to talk . work int he kitchen while they are snacking--that way they can talk without it being " a talk" Remember they wont be perfect--you weren't--help them overcome problems but remember dont be afraid to be the parent. Remember, sometimes they wont like you--but that wont last forever. Grounding is harder on the parent than the teenager (who wants a grumpy teenager in the house for days?) but sometimes it is necessary to make a point. Make them pay for part of their car insurance. Keep cell phones in your room at night--otherwise they talk or text all night. Keep the computer in the family room. Remember they grow up too fast---and these are the best years ever. Enjoy them.

      • 1 vote
      Reply#4 - Thu Oct 14, 2010 9:59 PM EDT

      global consultant you are so right on the money here!

      • 1 vote
      #4.1 - Fri Oct 15, 2010 4:17 PM EDT

      I am in total agreement with your comment. It was refreshing to read... my husband and I did not agree with the article.

        #4.2 - Sat Oct 16, 2010 9:41 PM EDT
        Reply

        Andrea -- you picked him. We really don't want to hear it. People need to live with their choices. The only victim in your paragraph is your daughter, whom had no choice about who her parents were going to be. Have some class and stop bashing her father on a public forum.

        • 2 votes
        Reply#5 - Fri Oct 15, 2010 9:22 AM EDT

        JEM 1989317

        "So much for teaching that "Christian Turn the Other Cheek" nonsense"

        It's absolutely NOT nonsense unless one hasn't done the research that teaches that whole passage is about forcing the roman soldiers to treat you as equals, not as a lower class.  STUDY!  READ IT IN CONTEXT!

        • 2 votes
        Reply#6 - Fri Oct 15, 2010 2:49 PM EDT

        WTF Andrea? Wow...let it go. He's a dick. We get it....your kid is 19 now. Get over yourself.

          Reply#7 - Sat Oct 16, 2010 8:05 AM EDT

          While this article touches on some important topics it could have also touched on some important concepts as well. For instance, teens/tweens begin to look more towards acceptance by their peers than their parents as part of the maturation process. Parants can't stop this and when they try to stop it they alienate their children. This article hits a home run with the concept of respect for the children. If you respect them they will not only return the respect to you but will also include respect in their daily interaction with others.

          Many parents don't lead by example. For instance, they will preach honesty to their children and punish them for not being honest but then turn around and try to take advantage of less then honorable situations at the store or with other people. Leading by example will rub off on the children if you want it or not. A dishonest person will raise dishonest children regardless of what the parent tries to enforce. Actions speak louder than words. Offspring are built to observe their parents for survivial.

          An expample of this is when I lost some money out of my pocket. The kids saw that I was dissapointed but we went on to enjoy the afternoon. soon after that, one of my daughters borrowed $20 from me at the store. After about 45 minutes we went to check out and she had lost the money. We retraced our steps but the money was never found. Later on, she repaid the $20 to me without hesitation and we breifly discussed the dissappointment in losing the money. That was about 6 months ago and I have never heard her talk about it since. She has since borrowed money from me and always paid it back in a reasonable time. I have not had to ask for it. She was 14 at the time. Now she's 15.

          Involving yourself in your childrens life does not mean you are thier BFF. It means understanding their interests and accepting their behavior. Children have other friends too. School friends and work friends are important to them. Children also need to know that you are not "Friending" them to spy on them or to preach morals.

          I tell my children that, as a parent, I have certain responsibilites to them and as kids they have expectations of me. If I don't perform my parenting role they will lose repsect for me and that impacts our relationship. I must correct them but I don't have to be overbearing about it. They know what is right and wrong. I cannot stop that behavior and I tell them that. They know how people get pregnant. They know why people go to jail. They know alot of things. All I can do is re-enforce what they already know and show them, by example, how to behave in those situations. Parents cannot "make" children behave in a manner they like. They can only provide examples and leadership. Treat them and talk to them as peers and they will treat and talk to you as a peer. That is all a parent can do. Remember when you were young and the things you did that you are not proud of. It's very difficult to ruin your life forever. They have to make mistakes and figure out how to recover from them using the expamples you provided for them. Otherwise they will never learn how to use the expamples you have provided.

          • 1 vote
          Reply#8 - Sat Oct 16, 2010 1:45 PM EDT

          The point of Andrea's comments are missed. I believe she wants all parents, divorced or not, to recognize the impact they have on their child. I don't believe she's trying to "air her grievances". She's stating, every child needs guidance, love, time and financial support from ALL parents involved. If only one parent can provide it for the child's success and mental health, then try to do it.

          Anyone who doesn't think Andrea's role as a parent to her daughter isn't ten times more difficult simply due to her ex-husband's manipulating behavior and the court system allowing him "rights" to hurt the child, should seek counseling as well. A co-parent like Andrea's ex-husband delays a child's development, causes resentment, seeks acceptance from peers for different reasons and often makes a child feel little self-worth. THIS causes great separation for the parent who has custody of the child. This teen is lost and doesn't understand. She leans on her custodial parent, then pulls away often blaming that parent and turning to peers. All of that is another layer of diffiuclty that Andrea is trying to get across.

          If for one moment, anyone thinks our children do not read the signals and listen to what all parents (even step parents) say at very young ages, then you need counseling or need to talk to your child more. At 4 years old, my daughter gave me clues about things within her school, watched conflicts with grandparents and at 10 could tell me much of what was happening within the homes of her peers. LISTEN to your children, watch what you do around them as well!

          Please don't throw Andrea down, suggest counseling or tell her "you picked him". She's making a valid point about co-parenting, even if she didn't get it out correctly. She needs us to recognize her value as a parent who has guided a teen who STATISCALLY could be failing, pregnant and/or lost. Parents must be parents. Not absent and not friends.

          Andrea-I praise you and understand the struggles you've gone through to raise this young woman. The two of you should be proud of yourselves and I, as a stranger am proud of both of you. If she ever decides she'd like to talk to her biological father, I know as her parent who has gone through so much it would be difficult to think about it for you’d be afraid she’d be hurt or rejected by him again. However, I hear in your message someone who loves and values their child, and I hope you'll support her fully. You may not like it, but you love your child and that is all that counts and what she knows and sees. As I always remind all of my children when you hate those who created you, you somewhat are hating yourself. Please try not to instill any hate towards him and his family from you or her. YOU are the best role model she knows to date. YOU don't hate one part of her and part of her would be her biological father. He has lost out and God will avenge for you when we leave this world if he doesn’t change and ask for forgiveness. Love her and through this love, it hurts him. Accepting him, not into your life as a friend, role model, good person, etc., but accept him because then you're accepting your daughter and she'll never, ever question her strength or self-worth. You deserve that for yourself, too.

          God loves you and I'll pray for you.

            Reply#9 - Sun Oct 17, 2010 8:52 AM EDT

            I both agree and disagree with this article. The 2 things I do agree on is that you do need to respect your children; they are their own individual person and they are worthy of respect. And to let your teen know you are on their side. However, I agree with Global Consultant in that children of all ages need to be aware that you are their parent, not their girlfriends or one of "da boyz" but their parent, and as such, you have the authority to raise them and discipline them as you see fit. Now that doesn't mean parents should be dictators or oppressors but they shouldn't be pushovers either.

            I'm a firm believer that parenting should be consistent all throughout kids' lives. Don't expect your moody 14-year old to respect your authority if you didn't assert said authority when they were younger. I'm a 23 year old mom to a quite temperamental 4 year old (it's in the genes, what can I say!). My son has a strong personality, and like pretty much every other child on earth, wants to have things done his way. However, ever since my son was a baby, I have asserted my authority over him. When he was about 1 year old, he started a bad habit of hitting people, and while others just laughed it off, I would very firmly say "No". If he did it again, I would say "No" and move his hand away. A third time, I would say "No" and tap him lightly on his hand. Of course, he would pout and cry but pretty soon, he stopped. Of course, as the youngest one in my family, I would receive lots of unsolicited advice and interference from others but I never changed my firm parenting technique. And I am proud to say I have only had to spank my child once in his 4 years of life (hey, I'm not perfect and he does have a strong personality).

            Now I am no parenting expert, I am only raising one child, but I can speak from my own experience. My parents raised me pretty much the same way I am raising my son. As the baby, I did get away with things my older siblings would never have dreamed of doing but for the most part I was well-behaved. The one thing my parents inadvertently instilled in all of us was a fear, not of them, but of dissapointing them. My parents always showed us that they respected us and that they were on our side. They also believed in us, that we could not only reach for the stars but that we were all good and kind human beings, and I for one, would hate to see my parents change their mind, as their opinion of me means more than I could possibly say. Of course my parents are not perfect and I do remember some pretty heated arguments during my teenage years but the one thing I never forgot was that they were my parents and as such, worthy of utmost respect. No, they were not my "home dawg skillets" but I knew that whenever I needed them, they would be there and that they would love me and respect me no matter what. And I can only hope, as my son grows (much too quickly :( ), that I can be the same for him.

              Reply#10 - Mon Oct 25, 2010 6:31 AM EDT

              I wish my parents had read this and considered it when I was a teen!

                Reply#11 - Wed Jan 5, 2011 1:18 PM EST

                I recently read a great resource for parenting, especially for dads of tween girls, that addresses these three issues: What Happened to my Little Girl? Here's a link to the Amazon page: It offers all sorts of helpful information that would be useful to parents to understand how to engage effectively with their children.

                  Reply#12 - Fri Apr 29, 2011 3:16 PM EDT
                  You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                  As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.