Are peanut allergy protections in schools going too far?

Live Poll

Are peanut allergy protections in schools going too far?

View Results
  • 142736
    Yes, all students shouldn't have to change their behavior for one child.
    44%
  • 142737
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.
    56%

VoteTotal Votes: 6141

Scroll down for poll results.

A group of parents in Edgewater, Fla., have been protesting to have a 6-year-old child removed from elementary school because of her severe allergies.

Hearing the details of the story, you might wonder: Are these parents going a little nuts?

The first-grader, the daughter of Tracey and David Bailey, has a rare, life-threatening peanut allergy and can't have the slightest exposure to someone who has eaten a product containing nuts. As Tracey Bailey told the website clickorlando.com, "We're not talking about she will break out in a rash. We are talking about she will die, stop breathing."

To protect Bailey's daughter, other first-graders have to wash their hands and rinse out their mouths twice a day before entering the classroom. Teachers also use Clorox wipes to clean desks. (Update: The school announced it would ease up on the mouth rinsing requirement.)

All this time spent sanitizing got some parents in such a tizzy, they brought signs to picket at the school last week. They say their kids are spending 30 minutes a day getting clean – time that could be spent on learning. Plus, their kids are missing out on holiday parties in the classroom with outside food. "They shouldn't have to lose out on what they should be able to experience at school," said Carrie Starkey, whose daughter is a classmate.

Watch TODAY video: Child's peanut allergy drives some parents nuts

Parents like Starkey want the Baileys' child to be home-schooled. But since her condition is covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act, the school is mandated to provide her a safe environment. Meanwhile, the Baileys feel bad about the classroom disruptions, but say it's a matter of protecting their daughter.

Parents who have kids with allergies empathize with the Baileys' ordeal of keeping their kid safe. In her popular blog, The Nut Free Mom, Jenny Kales of Chicago weighed in on the story:

The thing about food allergies is that it does require cooperation from others. And many times, people don't want to give it. Food allergies sometimes reveal what we are willing to do for other people. Some generous individuals want to help all they can; some want to hang on tight to their food "rights" and not give an inch. It's tough.

I know that emotions run high when it comes to our children, but I would ask those protesting if they would also protest accommodations made for children with cancer, diabetes or asthma?

Others take issue with the burden these peanut protections are putting on a bunch of 6-year-olds. Writes one commenter on the blog Jezebel:

I totally agree that it is "the obligation of the adults around her to make sure she is protected". Her parents are putting this burden on others though. If your child had such a severe allergy, would you really feel comfortable telling a school-full of children how to eat/drink/live? "Please rinse your mouth out or my kid will DIE". This isn't a run-of-the-mill allergy, if she *breathes* peanut she could die. I can't imagine how difficult this must be for her family, but they need to come to terms with how serious this is and not expect others to look out for their kids' near-constant threat of death.

By following the school's rules for sanitizing, it seems the kids in the classroom are cooperating and willing to help out their classmate. (And they get something out of it, too: the fantastic habit of hand-washing!)

Maybe they don't get to have birthday cupcakes or candy at their class Halloween party. But other then the occasional sugar high, are they really missing out?

--Posted By Kavita Varma-White

What do you think? Are peanut-allergy protections in schools going too far?

Results with 59 short comments
Total of 6,141 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

43.6%
Yes, all students shouldn't have to change their behavior for one child.
2,676 votes
56.4%
No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.
3,465 votes
Display Comments:
No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

seriously how is it hurting their education?? we have a peanut allergy in our school - WHAT IF IT WAS YOUR CHILD!!! THINK ABOUT IT!

  • 4 votes
 - MSPACH
 - 7:10 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
Yes, all students shouldn't have to change their behavior for one child.

I have a 7 year old son with a deadly peanut allergy. It is MY responsibility to teach him how to keep HIMSELFsafe. Its OUR issue!

  • 1 vote
 - 8:09 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
Yes, all students shouldn't have to change their behavior for one child.

To avoid so much controvery the school should become pnut free. That is what our school did. The other kids can eat pnuts at home!!!!!!!!!

  • 1 vote
 - 8:26 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

How much money and time missed from school for all students parents for medical dental bills from teaching good hygiene It could be their's

     - 8:33 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    I applaude the school system. Having children wash their hands protects everyone from cold and flu germs. Rinsing is only good oral hygene

    • 3 votes
     - 8:39 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    Parents that oppose to their children washing their hands for the life of another child is appalling!

    • 3 votes
     - 8:45 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    Kids aren't going to school for cupcake parties, they're there to learn. So let the girl get her education, take the party outside.

    • 3 votes
     - 9:07 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    These parents are all about me, me, me. I see it as an oppty to teach children to care for others. We could use some of that.

    • 2 votes
     - babina
     - 9:10 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    I am outraged that parents would do this to a child!! It's not the childs fault and good lesson can be learned here COMPASSION!!!!!

    • 1 vote
     - 9:17 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    our entire school is peanut free my child has severe allergies,peanuts the worse. Not one parent said a word. shame on them.

    • 2 votes
     - 9:31 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    Tell the family -to move to Eva, AL we will love and embrace and protect thier child. peanut free school !!!!!

    • 3 votes
     - 9:36 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    Parents/adults need to learn from kids. They have NO problems making accommodations for their classmates. Observe them sometime.

    • 2 votes
     - MNNA
     - 9:43 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    What are these parents teaching their kids by having them picket? Hope they never have to deal with a disability in their families.

    • 3 votes
     - 9:44 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    What are these parents teaching their kids by having them picket? Hope they never have to deal with a disability in their families.

    • 2 votes
     - 9:44 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    Where is compassion? Plus, washing hands help your kids from getting flu & cold viruses and rinsing mouth after lunch from getting cavitie

    • 3 votes
     - 10:00 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    Yes, all students shouldn't have to change their behavior for one child.

    I would like to know how many children died when nuts were still allowed in schools? Are we overreacting?... Doesn't she have an epi-pen?

    • 1 vote
     - 10:01 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    Am I not my brothers keeper? THE BIBLE

    • 1 vote
     - 10:03 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    Obviously,these parents havent rushed a child to the emergency room because they are in anapyhlatic shock after being exposed to peanuts in

    • 2 votes
     - 10:12 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    How petty and ridiculous for those parents to make an issue of this. What would they choose to do if it were their child?

    • 2 votes
     - 10:16 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    Once again Florida has a red face! Ms. Curry is correct, these parents have missed an opportunity to teach compassion and acceptance.

    • 3 votes
     - 10:18 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    Taking time to wash hands is not unreasonable. It is necessary for everyone's health. I am sad to know that this is such a problem.

    • 2 votes
     - 10:18 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    These parents in Florida should be ashamed! It's a small sacrifice to give up peanut butter for a year to keep this little girl safe!

    • 1 vote
     - 10:35 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

    Can't even believe this is an issue! How would the parents feel if this was their child? All children deserve the right to attend public sc

    • 2 votes
     - 10:38 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
    Yes, all students shouldn't have to change their behavior for one child.

    This is ridiculous. Kids washing hands? is that so bad? children should also not be picketing for adults, who are in all honesty just bored

       - 11:23 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011
      No, the protections are worth it for one child's safety.

      Grimy hands are a "right"? Thankfully no school requires a daily bath, else few students might attend in that town. :)

      • 1 vote
       - mac934
       - 11:40 am EDT on Thu Mar 24, 2011

      "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

      Discuss this post

      Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 ... 9

       I'm really sorry about this child's allergy...and I'm sorry for the fear that her parents deal with every day.  However, the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.  It's not right that the other children have to go to such extremes.  It's completely unreasonable.  If her allergy is that life threatening, she needs to be in a special school/area that is able to deal with that. The other children have a right to a good education and, while learning compassion, it is taking away from what they are in school for!

      • 4 votes
      #1 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:12 AM EDT

      You are an ignorant and hateful woman. God help you if your child developes something in life and NOBODY supports your child or you as a mother. Disgusting outlook.

      • 4 votes
      #1.1 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:24 AM EDT

      To Susan-2256455

      How are the other children learning compassion? No one ever said that the children are not getting a good education. Just because they have to wash their hands & wipe their face, that means they are not getting a good education. That does not even make sense.

      • 4 votes
      #1.2 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:33 AM EDT

      I cannot believe that these parents are not sympathetic to this child. I'm in CT and in when my kids were in the younger grades, we had peanut allergy kids ranging from rash to stop breathing and die. It was never a big deal for the kids to wash their hands after snack/lunch and also to have a no peanut butter/nut product snack rule for the classroom. Never, did any of us protest to get the child/children out of our school! Our kids just grew up knowing that some kids have allergies that could kill them and they need to wash their hands. The parent of the child/children also brought in wipes to the classroom so the kids could use them as well.

      Those parents should be ashamed of themselves for behaving this way and to be teaching their children that it's okay to make another child an outcast! They need now to be grateful that their child is healthy and doesn't have a disease that could could kill them. I hope for them, that they never have to experience something like this but, what if they did? What if their child needed a blood transfusion and developed AIDS. Remember, we are all fragile for something horrific to happen. What goes around comes around. It's called Karma.

      Shame, shame on you!

      • 5 votes
      #1.3 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:37 AM EDT

      This is becoming too much. "Extreme Measures." Really? "30 Minutes to wash hands." Really? A shower shouldn't take 30 minutes. Handwashing in two sinks and a wipe of the mouth for 32 children should take maybe 5 minutes. And it's not like it's pointless. It's basic hygiene. Anyways, back to the point. The parents who feel their children are being "stripped of their rights" are really willing to make the parents of the little girl with the life-threatening nut allergy go attend 'a special school/program' of sorts simply because they think it's wasting too much education time? Grow up.

      • 2 votes
      #1.4 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:38 AM EDT

      This is so sad that people wouldn't want to teach there children that it is OK to go out of there way to do and help others! This is a 6 yr old little girl with a life threatening allergy! Those of you who are against supporting this little girl WELL!!! you have issues BIG ONES!!! We are to teach our kids no matter what, do what ever it takes to help, keep her safe, and also teachs these kids an important responsability! thats a big one to teach these kids! little effort to do so and these adults have to whine about it...alls I can say you ought to be ashamed! To the parents of that little angel and the little angel her self...My prayers are with you!

      • 3 votes
      #1.5 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:41 AM EDT

      I agree you are an idiot. As a teacher, when the swine flu hit last year we had to ask kids to wash hands multiple times a day, sanitize desks daily, etc. I don't remember ANYONE complaining that this was unfair and it took time out of the children's education. Why? Because swine flu could infect everyone. People have no compassion. We are a selfish society.

      • 4 votes
      #1.6 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:45 AM EDT

      • 1 vote
      #1.7 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:52 AM EDT

      YOU SAD PATHETIC PERSON!

      My young son suffers from SEVERE food allergies, not just to peanuts. We own restaurants in which we now are the only one who manufacturers and sells a completely allergen free pizza....SO THAT EVERYONE IN A FAMILY CAN COME AND EAT.

      You have NO IDEA what it's like to come home and have your child want to "smell" what the non-allergen sufferers are eating since it's something that they really wish they could try.....Pizza, Chocolate Chip Cookies, Donuts, McDonalds.

      People look through such jaded glasses and it's so sad.

      However, in our case our son DOES sit with his friends at the regular cafeteria table....WHY?....we have educated our son from the beginning about his allergies and how to BE CAREFUL. Our school Principal made the same decision to remove snacks WHICH WE DO NOT AGREE WITH since we only asked that we be able to bring in a "like" snack for our son and that there be no nuts.

      Most kids with food allergies can eat Lay's potato chips; Swedish Fish; allergen free cookies or cupcakes. However, it DOES take some understanding from the parents on both sides and sometimes parents can be over-protective which can affect their child for a lifetime.

      I guess to conclude, when I run into ignorance such as this I ask one simple long-winded question: For the ignorant it's about your kids choice of which snack they WANT TO EAT...For us, it's about a snack that our child cannot eat -- OR THEY CAN DIE!

      I want one of these ignorant parents to go through what we go through! I want one of these blinded parents to experience what we had to experience -- November 2009 our young son came home from a neighbors house...walks into our home....leans against the hallway wall....starts a croupe (sp) style cough....falls to the floor....I pick him up and bring him to the couch while my wife calls 911....I pull out the Epi-Pen and he looks at me and with very little breathe he says "no daddy....please no daddy" at that point I had to jamb a long needle into his thigh in an effort TO SAVE HIS LIFE.

      SO....you are going to protest the fact that YOUR KID CAN'T HAVE A SCHOOL SNACK? I am not surprised since NONE of you have had to see your child say "no daddy....please no daddy."

      • 5 votes
      #1.8 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:52 AM EDT

        #1.9 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:55 AM EDT

        My question is....how many of those parents protesting have kids that have ADHD. I can guarantee you there is more lost education time dealing with ADHD kids in the classroom (I can say this because my son was ADD) than there is in washing hands twice a day (which should be done anyway). How would they feel if parents were protesting their kids being in the classroom. People who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones. Please take this opportunity to teach your children some compassion. Children need to learn to make sacrifices for others...it will make them more compassionate people and thats something this world could use a little more of. "There but for the grace of God go I."

        • 2 votes
        #1.10 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:01 AM EDT

        There are not special schools/areas that "deal" with it!! How would you feel if it were your child? You would want he/she to LIVE a full life: I would hope. Guess what her child as well as mine; also a severe peanut allergic (PA) child has a right and by law is required to have an education! You are saying the "few" children that are PA are not important enough to give them a safe environment and that their need don't matter! Selfish!! Does it actually hurt anyone by washing hands or other steps taken to protect someone else? NO, just gets rid of germs and in this case... poison as well! It is so sad that people just don't think of others unless it is them!

        • 3 votes
        #1.11 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:03 AM EDT

        Absolutely appalling. You should be ashamed of yourself as should those parents in Edgewater protesting the use of common hygiene to prevent a deathly allergic reaction. With all of the problems we are having with bullying in this country, we need to teach our children compassion and caring. Furthermore, how could you possibly consider twice daily hand washing and mouth wiping extreme? These should be common practices, regardless of allergies! Here in NYC most schools won't allow any foods with nuts just to prevent a possible allergic reaction. It's not extreme, it's safe.

        • 4 votes
        #1.12 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:20 AM EDT

        The parents at this school DO have compassion for the child and her allergy!!!!! All of you do not know all the facts!! Like how this child comes to school events like the school carnival, she went to Disney, goes shopping in the local grocery store, even trick or treating and eats at Applebees. So if this is life threatening does the parents have everyone she comes in contact with wash their hands, rinse their mouth out and wipe down the rides?

        I have a niece who is 7 years old who has the same allergy. My sister has educated her enough to ask if there are peanuts in anything she goes to eat. She carries an epi-pen just in case.

        They say if she smells peanuts she will die. I say shame on the parents for putting their child in harms way!! Their job is to protect her!! If this was my child I would have her home schooled which the county would pay for since she couldn't attend a public school. THe parents said they can't afford to pay for home schooling. The fact is that home schooling is paid for my the county so they are not telling the truth!

        As for the classroom celebrations if there is to be no treats for any of the classes what gives her parents the right to bring in treats for her class only!! How is that fair to the other 6 years old the school!!

        • 6 votes
        #1.13 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:28 AM EDT

        I can"t believe that parents will spend so much time and energy saying their kids are missing out on education. They are the cause of it. Some have pulled their kids out of school for 4 days, to prove What? Their children lost about 24 hours of education just so they can prove what point!?. Parents are the #1 role model. Sorry to say they are not teaching their children any morals with this matter. The only thing they are teaching is to be as selfish as they themselves are. What would they do if the child they love so much were to need help in any way? How would they feel if that poor little girl was to die because of their selfishness!

        • 5 votes
        #1.14 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:32 AM EDT

        DISGUSTING!!! You are talking about life and death! Simple hygiene and handwashing not only prevents DEADLY ALLERGIC REACTIONS but COMMON COLD and FLU which means LESS TIME is taken away from thier education! It is a ridiculous argument!! Stop wasting your child's time standing on the side of the road holding signs and take this time to educate your child on humanity, citizenship and personal hygiene!!!

        • 4 votes
        #1.15 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:37 AM EDT

        Give your children credit, they can do this. What is so terrifying? Your child will not be harmed by having to wash, or miss certain snack items. Your child needs to be safe and so does this little girl. Maybe you don't understand fully what anaphylaxis looks like or how quickly it can kill. While helping this little girl by making these minor accommodations, your child will learn love and tolerance.

        We had a child in our community with similar life threatening allergies. We worked as a community, with his doctors at Johns Hopkins, to carry out a program allowing him to stay in school and be safe, too. Our children learned that they could make small sacrifices and save this other child's life. Oh! How important they felt. It became their crusade! Helping this one child really helped our children just as much.

        The boy grew up, and grew out of many his life threatening allergies. He moved away but his family returns annually. They have spoken in many schools in the area. They are so grateful to this community. I have no doubt that the one child we kept safe by washing and going without popcorn and cupcakes for few years will repay us by doing great things. My children, who are in and going off to college, remember the whole thing....very, very well. They never mention the popcorn or the cupcakes.

        They remember that they helped someone.

        • 4 votes
        #1.16 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:52 AM EDT

        It disappoints me so much to see those we "trust" to report the news, do not even use their common sense when reading the news or interviewing. It is so hard to listen to "acclaimed" reporters discuss the issues. Really, wasn't it a while back when you reported on how it takes at least one minute, 60 seconds or a round of "Happy Birthday" for a person to wash their hands effectively! So let's do a word problem in math and ask for the elementary answer for the school's representative to tell the truth.

        If there are 28 students who need to wash their hands twice a day. Their are two available sinks. Proper hand washing takes 1 minute or 60 seconds each. In addition, each child must also wash or wipe their mouth, dry their hands, throw away the towel, turn water on and off, and hopefully clean up their mess; so let's say 5 seconds. How long does it take for this class to wash their hands twice a day? How much time is spent weekly, washing hands by these students?

        28x2= 56 hand-washings a day

        Each hand washing takes 65 seconds

        56 hand-washings at 65 seconds each = 3640 seconds or 60.66 minutes or approximately 1 hour.

        Since their are 2 sinks, this time can be reduced in half resulting in a truly effective time of 30 minutes because we know children are like little robots and there will be no need for any supervision or direction and no mayhem.

        Since there are 5 school days a week, a typical week will require us to multiply this 30 minute process by 5 resulting in 2 1/2 hours a week. Perhaps, someone should have called the school representative on her blatant misinformation.

        Why do you continue to report such illogical reports and/or let those you interview lead you around by the ring in your noses like you think we all possess. I have switched on your show 3 times in the last month and all three times caught you in blatant errors on reporting. Today a had a minute to waste - obviously since I was listening to your reports - so I decided to send you a note in hopes that you will require more infantile fact checking before you take a stand as do good reports to the masses.

        Please be responsible if you are given the privilege of reporting the news. It used to be an honor now its just nonsense dribbling from mouth of one seeking to exploit for popular ratings? No wonder, most people count on Comedy central and satirists for the REAL news.

        • 2 votes
        #1.17 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:03 AM EDT

        To NOT THE CASE: So your saying that little girl can't have a normal life, like shopping and Disney world, because your against hand washing and oral hygiene?

        • 4 votes
        #1.18 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:04 AM EDT

        As a first year teacher, I have quite a few concerns with this situation...

        1. This child has every RIGHT to receive a public education as any other child in this country. So you can't bring in peanut butter birthday treats, big deal. Consider your own feelings if this was your child. Would your want you baby in a life threatening situation because an ignorant parent felt it was their child's "right" to put a classmate at risk with nutty foods?

        2. Is this the 1950's? I thought segregation was ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court? The young girl already must sit alone with only her para to eat lunch each day. How much more do you want her to feel distant and separated from her schoolmates? Really. Lunch and recess are just about the only time when kids get to unwind from academia and socialize for fun with other children. Socialization skills are extremely important in young school years. What if a beautiful, vibrant personality is being completely suppressed by a solitary eating environment. Again, would you want your baby to eat lunch alone day after day? No, you want them to have all the friends and positive experiences as possible throughout their day. Does the child with PA deserve to be alone?

        3. What if teachers ignored YOUR child's exceptionalities? Oh, that child has autism, so kick her out. That boy hasn't taken his ADHD meds today, so send him home. Seriously- never going to happen? If teachers had this attitude, every single one of the students in our classroom would be "taking away others' rights" according to the attitudes of these FL parents. Similarly, children with other exceptionalities than allergies can also disrupt and take away instruction time in their own way...as even a group of chatty, unfocused children can. They're kids- they get off task sometimes, and they aren't supposed to be perfect.

        4. As one mother thinks, it does NOT take 30 instructional minutes out of a day for elementary students to was their hands and wipe their mouths twice in a school day. As an intern in Kindergarten, it only took us a maximum of 10 minutes to do this- mind you, with a bunch of giddy kiddos who had never been in a public school routine before. Teachers know that young children need breaks throughout the day. Their attention spans scientifically don't last 8 hours, and guess what, like you, they need restroom breaks during the day. If these hand washing times, as I'm sure they are, are built into 2 bathroom/hand washing breaks throughout the day, they're not taking away any intended teaching time at all. In addition, hand washing is a good practice and kills germs. Yay for good hygiene.

        5. Lastly, the "protest" is too much. Wow. A sign that reads "No Dogs." You should be ashamed of yourselves. C'mon people, really? As an educator, it almost brought me to tears. No child deserves that kind of ruthless pain ADULTS are bringing upon her. Judge the log in your own eye before you judge the speck in someone else's. In school, we strive to teach our students good citizenship, fairness, respect and equity. What are you modeling as a parent to reaffirm positive character building at home? By protesting, making a scene and alienating one student, you're totally making that progress regress. Is it your child or YOU, a grown adult, who really has the issue here?

        For those of you who agree that every child in this free country is entitled to a public, quality education, regardless of his/her exceptionalities, I applaud you. Thank you for your positive attitude!

        • 3 votes
        #1.19 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:05 AM EDT

        I think all these people should be ashamed of them selves to say this little girls life is not worth their child having to wash their hands.I would like to see how these people live it must be gross if they have such a problem with hand washing.what if it was your child that did not wash their hands and killed this little girl do you want that on your shoulders I think not. So come on people grow up and think of other I mean really what is this world coming to if we can not come together as a community for the life of a child all of you people should be ashamed of yourself. You should teach your child better morals than that...

        SHAME ON YOU PEOPLE!!!!!!!

        • 2 votes
        #1.20 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:26 AM EDT

        Bravo to all the posters who agree that the handwashing is necessary in daily life for many reasons, not just the peanut allergy issue!

        For those opposed to 'wasting time' to wash hands, how do you feel when flu season rolls around or their is an outbreak of swine flu or Rota virus? Are you going to protest handwashing then? Not to mention just washing after using the bathroom.

        Handwashing is very important. This is part of the school helping make a safe environment for ALL!

        • 3 votes
        #1.21 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:29 AM EDT

        In response to the mom who felt it was too much to ask for children in school to wash their hands to help the peanut allergic children be safe, shame on you. I have raised 3 children and now am raising 2 of my grandchildren and I have always taught them to be compassionate towards others especially their fellow students who might be different from them. No one asks to be born with an allergy or disability whether physical or mental so why should they be treated as if it were their fault. God only knows what tomorrow holds and one day it could be our child in that situation. We have to teach our children to be compassionate towards all. If we as parents and grandparents instilled that in our children at a young age then maybe we wouldn't have to worry about kids bringing guns to school and shooting others who are intolerant towards them. My best friend has a child who is peanut allergic and her son had to be rushed to the emergency room after a school Christmas party due to ignorance on the teachers part. The school had already been informed of her son's condition and yet because of the same attitude as the woman who posted above he ended up in the hospital and nearly lost his life. He is the most precious 5 year old you ever want to meet and he almost died because of the same attitude as above. Why should he be singled out, why should he have to eat in a hallway away from all of his friends. He has the same right as all the others in that school including the right to not be singled out. The world is the way it is today because of parents like this woman who breeds intolerance. God forgive them.

        • 3 votes
        #1.22 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:51 AM EDT

        There has always been someone who is different and it takes effort from good people to help them fit in. We have made it from the days of segregated schools to integrated schooling. We have built wheelchair ramps, food pantries and autism awareness. There are so many obstacles that we have overcome in the past to help children get through life as smooth as possible. This decade we are working on helping the growing number of young people with food allergies fit in.

        If you are not a part of the solution, you are part of the problem.

        • 3 votes
        #1.23 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:54 AM EDT

        I think all of these comments are nonsense. I have a son that has a severe peanut allergy and also other food allergies along with grasses, trees, and molds. When he was between 3-4 years of age he was tested and found to have a severe reaction to peanuts and at that time he had a slight reaction for green peppers but now he was tested resently and he has more food allergies and almost everything environmetnal. My son went to the school in question and the only thing I had to do was to make sure they had medication in the nurses office if anyhting was to happen. My son has known what he can and can't eat since he was 4 years old and in daycare. He is in middle school now and has not had any problems. I don't see how these type of plans will work when the child gets to middle school and high school. These schools are probably double the size and a lot more kids and these procedures will not work in that type of situation. Peanut is the MOST common food allergy and a lot of people do have it. I can't believe that someone would actually compare ADHD to a peanut allergy. Besides all of my son's allergies he is also ADD and I see no comparison to the two issues. A child that is ADHD or ADD gets no special treatment in school. I guess I should have my child taken out of PE because is so allergic to grass and trees but instead he gets penalized at school if he does not dress out and participate in what they are doing outside. If my son has any type of reaction or starts having breathing difficulties he could have a major problem because he also has asthma issues. I am not out there trying to change everything just for him and if his life was in jeopardy I would personally keep him home to protect him. I even have a friend that has a child with a life threatening problem and in a sense he has lived most of his life like a boy in a bubble. He essentualy does not have an immune system. At one point she tried to let him attend school but the risk became to great so she continues to home school.

        I am not complaining about the hand washing but I do think that this whole situation is getting completely blown out of proportion but I guess some people like all the attention.

        • 1 vote
        #1.24 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 12:38 PM EDT

        I too am a mom to a 7 year old with severe food allergies. Like this little girl my son cannot smell or touch it. At first I planned on home schooling so I didn't have to be a burden on others but after talking to our WONDERFULLY accepting school we decided to send him. It is AMAZING how compassionate his classmates are even begging their own parents not to send them to lunch with a cookie so they can sit with my son at lunch in his special room. They all look out for him and are so accepting and concerned about his condition.

        It made me literally sick to my stomach seeing those innocent kids out there picketing being subjected to their parents (who are supposed to be their role models) PURE HATE! The still shots of that protest could have been made into black and white and been passed off for a scene from the 1950's!! it's DISGUSTING!

        To all your ignorant people out there, THERE ARE NO SPECIAL SCHOOLS TO SEND OUR KIDS TO! And yes us food allergy parents have heard of an epi pen! apparently you've never had to STAB your child who is gasping for air and clinging to life while you yourself are scared and shaking It's not that easy to do.

        I can't imagine if it came time for my child to go to school and we were treated like this being called a Dog! it seriously makes my chest ache at the thought.

        There is a thing called Soy Nut Butter out there. If your child NEEDS that taste THAT badly switch to it! it's the same taste and same cost!

        PLEASE teach your child acceptance of others regardless of who they are!

        • 2 votes
        #1.25 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 1:02 PM EDT

        I could not agree with you more.

        Thoughts from another teacher expanding on what was already stated:

        1. Hand washing is a good thing.

        2. Discriminating against a child who, by law, has every right to be in a public school (whether parents like it or not) is a bad thing. A teachable moment is being missed! In a situation like this, a community could come together and parents could be teaching their children to show compassion for each other. Instead, all those parents are teaching their children is how to bully on a large scale.

        3. So, cupcakes are out. Are we not in the middle of dealing with numerous childhood obesity problems in our country? Has it gotten that bad that telling our kids to put the snack cakes down causes such withdrawals that we need to protest? Childhood obesity is an actual problem to fight that is currently resulting in the risk of potential heart-related diseases and health problems for all children.

        4. I would rather teach my children the importance of sharing our time on Earth with all kinds of people (because the differences will never change) and making the most of it, than teaching them they should only think about themselves. I wonder who will want to help those ignorant parents, god forbid, they should ever have to go through something similar. It is always easier to throw stones when you are not the one in the situation.

        5. Pictures of children holding up picket signs against a fellow 1st grader disgust me. Those pictures literally showcase the destruction of childhood innocence. They are too young to be a part of so much anger that I am sure they do not even understand. Those protesting parents are setting this little girl up to be shunned by her peers. Has anyone considered how the little girl might be feeling about herself at this moment?

        6. No one can control what the parents do. They are protected by law and it is no one's choice, agree or disagree, what type of school they put their child into, but their own. What we can control is how we react to the situation. With that said...

        News Flash Parents: Taking your students out of school to protest that they are losing precious educational time in school is simply stupid. School is for learning about the rigorous courses, becoming a well-rounded healthy person, and learning how to work together in a larger picture of life. Ganging up on a family who never wished such an allergy on their daughter to avoid your children washing their hands is acting anything but educated. Sometimes the largest lessons are in what we will do for each other.

        7. I cannot even believe that we are giving those parents 15 minutes of fame as a reward for their ignorance. It is the kind of thing that makes it so easy to lose faith in humanity and yet, makes it so clear to see why so many students act the way they do. We are knee deep in wars and natural disasters. Imagine what could happen if those picketing parents put their minds to something useful and actually used their energy to help someone other than themselves?

        • 2 votes
        #1.26 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 1:51 PM EDT

        I AM FLABERGASTED at the reaction of these selfish, unsympathetic, uneducated parents that think the student with food allergies should not be allowed in class!! As a mother of a son with a special need (low vision) I would NEVER expect nor would the school that my son attends reactions as these people have reacted. Yet another reason to attend private school!!

        Instead of arguing about this topic how about teaching our kids compassion, understanding and acceptance of those that are less fortunate than others. As a parent I am just appalled at the behavior and expectations from parents these days--and to have your children "picketing" in front of the school displays poor judgement and lack of intelligence from those parents.

        Get with the program folks or you will be the next one on the news when your child is making "bigger" headlines than this.

        • 1 vote
        #1.27 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 2:20 PM EDT

        I am shocked and saddened to see the parents reactions and picketing due to a students deadly peanut allergy! If this was their child, wouldn't they want the same protection??? What are these parents teaching their children by having them at the picket line with them because another student has a peanut allergy????! This poor little girl not only has to live with a scary peanut allergy, but must have to feel pressure and rejection from her fellow students. My daughter has a student with a peanut allergy in her class, and it's NO problem whatsoever to accommodate him. The washing hands twice daily will minimize sickness as well. I hope the school continues to support and embrace this young child!

        • 1 vote
        #1.28 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 7:19 PM EDT

        I'm so glad that I came to this site and read these posts. I have 3 of my 4 children who have a peanut allergy. They live a normal life for the most part. One was life flighted halloween day (before trick or treat) due to eating a treat that had peanut butter and was not clearly marked that it had such. I've been so discouraged by the mean spirited people who have no sympathy for our children. They have a condition that requires special attention....just as ADHD, Diabetes, etc would. It is not in their control and their is no medical treatment for it...YET!

        Thank you to the teachers who have stood up for these children for it really is a burden on them not the kids. Every child we have asked to wash hands or keep their food away for our kids was more than happy to help. When my daughter went to the hospital I learned how selfless kids really can be. Maybe I'm just blessed to live in a caring community.

        How absurd do these parents protesting and supporting the protesters sound because their kids are being asked to wash their hands. To spend time calculating how much time it takes for that to happen...really? If my kids aren't washing their hands at school I will be really upset (allergy or no)! That's disgusting! And if my kids came home with food all over their face I wouldn't be too happy either. I'm sure they wanted hands washed when H1N1 was going around!

        The child eats in her classroom by herself. The kids can eat PB in the cafeteria. You want to have a classroom party? There are plenty of foods to choose from and our school encourages healthy choices. But if you want a treat bring in some ice cream, pizza, fruit snacks, yogos, gogurts, fruit roll-ups...the list can go on. There are plenty of choices out there.

        Remember the saying, "It take a village to raise a child"? Well these people are making it clear that its every man for himself. God forbid anything happen to any of their children and someone stand by and say "That's unfortunate but I don't need to disrupt my day to help". And by the way ignorant protesters. Read your signs...the saying is "Happy medium" not "happy median". Go find something more important to keep in school, not junk food. How about the arts, music, althletics, new equipment for teachers.

        Again, thank you teachers for keeping my children safe!

        • 1 vote
        #1.29 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:38 PM EDT

        People need to look at both sides of it. Allergies suck. No doubt about it. But what happens when that girl hits 18? Is she going to demand that her college campus or workplace go through such extreme measures? Or is she going to take responsibility for her own allergy and get allergy shots and treatments to lessen or completely negate the affect (they have such stuff, I was offered that for my wheat and tea allergies)? What she is going to practice in the future is what she should be starting to practice now.

        Plus, FAPE stands for Free and Appropriate Education. Personally, I doubt that smell alone can set off a deadly reaction, or opening a loaf of bread or standing next to someone drinking iced tea would have done me in years ago, but for the sake of argument I'll go along with it. In that case, "appropriate" sounds like she should be kept from all sources of transmission until the above-mentioned shots and medicines can take affect.

        Speaking of transmission, what does this family do during the 18 hours a day the girl is not in school? How do they take her grocery shopping? Walk through the food court of the mall? Cross paths with a family who just finished Grandma's famous peanut butter cookies? Why is this girl absolutely fine during the rest of the day?

        And if I understand peanut allergies correctly, the allergy is to all legumes. Yet I've heard from many families who claim a peanut allergy yet still admit to feeding their kids green peas (a closely related legume). Why would families risk a reaction if the allergy is really as severe as they claim?

          #1.30 - Fri May 11, 2012 9:25 PM EDT
          Reply

          I'm amazed that anyone would say it's not fair...it's not fair that this child has a life threatening allergy!! If there was something simple you could do to save a child's life wouldn't you do it...really...washing your hands isn't a big deal...I can't even imagine that there would be any debate...a peanut butter sandwich or a life...is it really a question????

          • 3 votes
          Reply#2 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:19 AM EDT

          KRISTEN, ADRIENNE, AND KRISTY... thank GOD there are normal, caring individuals like yourselves who can TAKE A SECOND to feel someone else's pain- put yourself in someone else's shoes-- some of you need to go to that school in Florida and tell them what's up!! : ) I have 3 kids, and so far, no allergies, but dammit... I'd do what I had to so my babies' friends are OKAY in school, or wherever

          • 3 votes
          #2.1 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:38 AM EDT

          Maggie Thank you. It is hard everyday sending a child to school even though there are precautions does not mean one day we will not have a reaction.

          • 1 vote
          #2.2 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:20 AM EDT

          really? it is already been proven it is life threatening and they and seems like you don't care either way anyway! what would that solve? research first .

            #2.3 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:35 AM EDT
            Reply

             I totally feel for these parents. As a parent of a child with sever food allergies who could go into anaphlaxis from egg or dairy, he is also has a peanut and wheat allergy.  I understand their concern. I have been lucky my school has worked with me to protect my child. We have made an arrangement to have my son eat at an allergy free table for lunch, the children in the classroom wash their hands after snacks and lunch. I have had no backlash from any of the parents in my school because of the accommodations the school has taken. It is unreasonable that parents of children with no allergy expect this child to be moved. What about accommodations for a child with diabetes or in a wheelchair. I am outrage that parents can be this selfish to believe that washing hands takes time away from school. What about hygeine.

            • 3 votes
            Reply#3 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:21 AM EDT
            Reply

            I agree with what the schhol is doing. I also have a child with a peanut allergy. Our school has made changes also like not serving peanut butter cookies and soon on. This child should not have to be kept out of school. She has every right to be there as well as the other kids. What if it happened to a child whose parents oppose this? Then it would be a different story. We should put ourselves in the shoes of the parents of this child. Would we be willing to let our children lose their life? I don't think so.......

            • 3 votes
            Reply#4 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:21 AM EDT

            There is a school in my area that has 1 child attending that also has peanut allergies. The school has banned all foods that may potentially contain peanuts.

            • 2 votes
            #4.1 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:23 AM EDT
            Reply

            Will milk and milk products be banned next? What about blooming plants? Will they be banned because of asthma? Where does it stop?! This is ridiculous. Taking away the rights of many for the safety of one is unconstitutional.

            • 3 votes
            #5 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:21 AM EDT

            LIFE THREATENING ALLERGY. Do you get what that means? Think if it was you. Very selfish outlook. PROTECT ALL CHILDREN, especially those with medical concerns.

            • 5 votes
            #5.1 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:27 AM EDT

            PEOPLE if it was YOUR kid with an allergy you'd CRY cuz you want them to be able to lead as normal life as possible... WHICH INCLUDES attending public school.... POOR MOMMIES, your kids have to wash their hands twice a day so SOMEONE ELSE'S WON'T DIE... how selfish are these parents that can't GET WITH THE PROGRAM.... a little girl DIES or your kid washes his hand. Like I said, if it was YOU or YOUR kid I can GUARANTEE you'd be on the other end....

            • 2 votes
            #5.2 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:31 AM EDT

            The whole RIDICULOUS and WHEN WILL IT STOP thing.... people don't DIE because they drink Milk, Cheryl... it's lactose INTOLERANT... not LACTOSE DEATH! Get real, this is a LITTLE baby girl with a REAL medical issue--- hey- let's just ALL be ignorant and send EVERYONE with an allergy or medical issue to an isolated island and then NONE of you will ever have to concern yourself with someone else's well being!

            • 3 votes
            #5.3 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:36 AM EDT

            Maggie 3225646: MILK ALLERGY is an allergy to the milk protein. Lactose intollerance is the inability to digest the milk sugar. Lactose intolerance is not an allergy. Educate yourself. And side note - your ignorance has nothing to do with THIS little girl with peanut allergies. She has a far worse scenario, so focus.

              #5.4 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:43 AM EDT

              This type of issue always seems to bring out the ignorant in the computer literate. It puzzles me that people with such limited intellect can even figure out how to post a message, much less form sentences, so kudos to the barely functional. I am happy to see the logical, educated and compassionate comments far outweighing the intolerant ones.

              • 3 votes
              #5.5 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:47 AM EDT

              @maggie - Actually you can be allergic to milk. Lactose intolerance is to the sugar in milk but you can have an allergy to the protein in milk which can cause anaphylaxis. Everything else you said is accurate.

                #5.6 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:08 AM EDT

                You are ridiculous! This is a life of a child!!!! Most allergies are not life threatening but for those that are precautions need to be taken you idiot!!! My son has been secluded and eats in the hallway for his lunch...would you like your child to eat in the hallway everyday? Think before you speak...please. Ignorance does not excuse stupid comments. You may want to read the constitution! All men are created equal allergies/disabilities or not! How are your rights being compromised? It is pathetic that the other kids are willing to help and do right and the parents are being Jerks!!!

                • 2 votes
                #5.7 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:20 AM EDT

                All due respect, it stops when there are not life threatening allergies. As for your comparison to a milk allergy, which I can sympathize with (I knew someone who died because of one) there is a difference. A peanut reaction can be triggered by just a trace of peanut oil coming in contact with the child's skin. A milk allergy is triggered when it is ingested. So, there isn't a need for a ban of milk in schools.

                • 1 vote
                #5.8 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:29 AM EDT

                I beleive it's unconstitutional to take away anyone's rights! How can you begin to even decipher who's rights outweigh others???? Thankfully there is a disability act for your kind of thinking. How is handwashing and mouth rinsing taking away someone's rights anyway, it's called good hygiene!

                • 1 vote
                #5.9 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:31 AM EDT

                I suppose you think that stopping for school buses or school crosswalks are infringing on your rights. I guess you don't see the benefit of handwashing either.

                • 1 vote
                #5.10 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:07 AM EDT

                I am so proud that my child was completely appalled at these parent's actions. He felt horrible that a child who already lives a life of minor isolation due to her allergies is now being further isolated by the willful actions of others. The amount of time spent washing hands is quickly made up by the amount of sick days these children do not have because of their good hygiene. They should be thankful their kids are receiving an opportunity to shine and show their support for someone. It is unfortunate they are wasting that opportunity.

                I pray for that little girl's emotional pain she must be feeling right now.

                • 2 votes
                #5.11 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:18 AM EDT

                Thank you "Proud-3226195"!!! I am so glad there are other parents who are disgusted with the residents of this town! I would be embarrassed to call myself a resident there! How selfish of these parents to take this stand against this beautiful, fragile child! I also am proud of my own kids who had open mouths watching this segment! They were completely surprised that people could be so callous! What an opportunity this could have been for showing your child how to be compassionate, accepting and caring for another human being! I also agree that washing their hands twice a day only contributes to cutting down germs and sickness of the other students.

                It takes a village to raise a child--I guess not this particular village! To involve your kids in picketing outside the school! I am outraged! They are being taught only selfishness and hate towards another human being! Wow! How naive I am that I would think people would not put their own small inconvenience ahead of a child's life!

                Does it take away too much time in your life to hold the door open for someone in a wheelchair? Does it take too much time to help a blind person cross the street? Come on!

                • 2 votes
                #5.12 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 11:52 AM EDT
                Reply

                I have been a preschool teacher for almost 10 years now and I believe that this much of an uproar about washing hands is ridiculous. Parents should be concerned about why their children haven't been required to wash their hands already. In my classrooms we were all (students and teachers alike) required to wash our hands upon entering the classroom at any time, before and after eating, and after touching any bodily fluids. This shouldn't even be a discussion, the children should already be required to wash their hands at all of those times. Frankly, they are at other schools without kids with allergies. Also the entire school was a nut free zone, I wasn't even allowed to have a peanut butter sandwich on my lunch break in the work room. Parents need to look at the good side of their children washing their hands that much, a severe reduction in the spread of germs! What has our society come to where washing your hands a few times a day is a bad thing? It is required in most schools!

                • 1 vote
                Reply#6 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:21 AM EDT

                AMEN! I agree wholeheartedly. While watching this piece on the Today Show, the main thought I had was that they should be washing their hands regularly anyway!

                  #6.1 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:24 AM EDT
                  Reply

                  Seriously, shame on you parents for being so selfish. What if this was your child? And what are you teaching your kids by having them out there with signs. Shouldn't we be teaching our children compassion and understanding. After all there seems to be enough bullying going around. I just cannot believe that we have become such a nation that we would protest the protection of a child. Again, shame on you!!!!!!!!!!!! Also, what is so wrong about having the children was their hands?

                  • 2 votes
                  Reply#7 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:22 AM EDT

                  Thank you! Well said!

                  • 1 vote
                  #7.1 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:28 AM EDT

                  A generation of children that have so much opportunity, access to material things we wouldn't have conceived of owning when we were children, can't accommodate a fellow classmate out of compassion? Practice a little humility? Become generous as children rather than really understanding what life is all about only when they become adults? Shame on the parents picketing the school, complaining about parties in the classroom? I'm sorry... don't "parties" take away from learning time? Isn't the greatest education EXPERIENCE? The parents protesting are fools and teaching a terrible lesson. And it looks like they are out of luck... this little girl is protected. She has the right and deserves the same opportunities in life experiences. Don't make it a bad one!!

                  • 1 vote
                  #7.2 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:40 AM EDT
                  Reply

                  Today Show,

                  I believe you left an important issue out this morning! As we should all teach our children compassion what about at the 4 year old level? These kids are attending full day classes and are NOT allowed to have a snack during the day. If there are so many kids with allergies, put them together! But I have a feeling there is not as many as you say! I had this same issue with our school in Greece New York and didn't get anywhere.

                    Reply#8 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:23 AM EDT

                    If they are attending full day classes, I am quite sure they are getting lunch. If a snack is such a concern for you have one waiting on the table for when your child gets home (only a couple hours after lunch).

                      #8.1 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:46 AM EDT

                      Trust me they are stil gettinga snack, the parents are just ticked because they have to make sure that its a peanut free snack. And just a little look into the rest of he world, most schools (the ENTIRE school) is a peanut free zone! But if you listen to the special at all their main concern is the amount of time spent washing their hands...really? ugh, parents, most of them are idiots. (I'm an expert on the stupidity of most parents, I've taught for almost 10 years)

                      • 1 vote
                      #8.2 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:02 AM EDT

                      Seriously we're whining about kids not getting a snack! They get lunch and they're only there for what 6 hours a day. I'm only 29 and the only time we ever got a snack at school was during the ISTEP tests! That clearly was NOT the important issue in this story it was the total ignorance of truly selfish people!

                      • 1 vote
                      #8.3 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:08 AM EDT

                      snack is not the issue...LIFE is. my children go to school all day long and no snack offered for no reason but they are not offering them! wahhhhh they will not starve i promise, my children come home everyday live and well... i provide them with a snack immediately and they are just fine. no harm done just as no harm in washing hands or any other steps in looking out for other and protecting them. my children like washing hands and taking care of others everyday without thought! they will grow to wonderful and compassionate adults...who could ask for more?

                      • 1 vote
                      #8.4 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 10:46 AM EDT

                      This story was NOT newsworthy. The children in the video holding signs stating that their rights were being violated looked as if they had not a clue as to why they were there. The whole tempest was clearly initiated by uninformed and I might add MEAN-SPIRITED ADULTS. All children should was hands at least twice in school day anyway, and as far back as I remember children have always lined up to use the lavatory at set times throughout the day. Hand washing is a normal part of toileting, or at least it should be. Hands should be clean after 15 seconds or a chorus of "Happy Birthday". Those mothers should be ashamed. Moreover, it is high time that they understand that their children need to learn that life is NOT all about them!

                      • 2 votes
                      #8.5 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 1:08 PM EDT

                      I think a very important point is being missed here. A child could potentially die from a peanut allergy & many have. I think schools should take certain precautions to ensure the safety of children, but ultimately this responsibility rests on the parents. How severe is the allergy? Are you willing to put complete trust in the school? What if a child had peanut butter on toast for breakfast & a small amount is on their clothes? How can a school provide 100% protection to any one child? Is the school nurse in the school every day & every hour? Personally, I would not risk my child's life if they had a life threatening allergy. Home schooling is an option and most of the time it is free. If parents have to work then hire a tutor. I think it is unfair to make another child's safety the responsibility of a 7 yr old. This can very well traumatize that child especially if the sick child had an unfortunate exposure to the peanuts or allegens. They may feel responsible for that child's death. Too many parents put too much of their child raising into the hands of teachers, school nurses, coaches etc. If you cannot be with your child, then please don't give birth to them. Sometimes, I think that successful people have children as the icing on the cake, rather than love of the child. By the way, most snacks are made in facilities that contain peanuts, so even a seemingly safe snack could be dangerous.

                      • 2 votes
                      #8.6 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 11:12 PM EDT
                      Reply

                      Are parents really upset that their children have to wash their hands? Think of the germs they are avoiding! More importantly, these parents are missing an important opportunity to teach their children about compassion for others. They have the chance to help save someone's life simply by avoiding peanuts, washing up & rinsing their mouths. That's so easy! How will these kids learn to make sacrifices for others in need if their parents protest something so simple? This is one of the most selfish things I've ever heard of.

                      • 1 vote
                      Reply#9 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:23 AM EDT

                      I am appalled by this community! I have a daughter with a peanut allergy and I can't imagine if the people in my town were so inconsiderate and small minded that they would have picketed her and her right to go to school. In our town we have a peanut free lunch table where children with that allergy sit. I can tell you that her friends actually asked their parents not to pack items with peanuts so they could sit with her. I NEVER had an issue with a parent thinking it was "taking away" their children's rights to be proactive in the matter. How would they feel if that was their child? These people are selfish and are sending a message to their children that if someone is not "like them" then they are not normal. This is so sad. Imagine how that poor little girl feels.

                      • 1 vote
                      Reply#10 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:23 AM EDT

                      I have friends with peanut allergy. I believe the parents are going a little over board. The questions that need to be asked is how bad does the child react to peanuts. Most people have get a stuffy nose when there is peanut smell in the air. I believe that a doctor needs to conduct a allergy test on this child and present it to the board and give his or her professional oversight on how the school should handle. This should be a public meeting so that all other parents can ask questions. The only way that this is going to get settled is if everyone gets educated.

                      • 2 votes
                      Reply#11 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:24 AM EDT

                      god love her... but if you have ever had children,, at six years old washing the hands are not their number one focus.. sure they wash their hands but then you look at them and they are still dirty.. and usually they have to "go wash them again..." if something should happen which one of the happy little 6 yr olds are going to feel the guilt? I would think if she wore a mask and gloves that would suffice have they tried that? If they can send a kid to school in a air tight suit why can't this little girl have a stricter wardrobe. Again I feel for this child but I also feel for the potential little unwilling murderers in her class.

                      • 3 votes
                      Reply#12 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:24 AM EDT

                      a mask and gloves???? Seriously???? why should this little girl have to do that when all it takes is the other kids to wash thier hands and face after eating. They should be washing thier hands after they go to the bathroom anyways! Whats wrong with proper hygene??

                      • 2 votes
                      #12.1 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:49 AM EDT

                      Logic - Air tight suit is probably for children susceptible to a great number/all airborne pathogens. That far exceeds this childs concerns, which is one- peanuts. Also, would you honestly send your child to school for SEVERAL years wearing gloves and a mask? Really? Even if the way around it was to simply have all the children do what they should all be doing in the first place, e.i; wash their hands?

                      • 1 vote
                      #12.2 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:51 AM EDT

                      I have a daughter with a peanut allergy. When she starts school in the fall she will have to eat lunch at a seperate table from her friends. Isn't that going to be hard enough for a 5 year to understand? She already has a complex about her allergy. A face mask and gloves? Really? She doesn't have a contagous disease! She is a little girl with feelings who did not ask to be burdoned with this allergy for the rest of her life. School is hard enough these days for our children. Why do uneducated, inconsiderate people have to make things harder. Washing hands is a small task to keep children like mine safe. I feel sorry for kids with allergies. But I pitty the people who feel like washing hands for one child isn't fair to the rest. Get over yourself! All the problems we have in the world today and people want to complain about hand washing!

                      • 2 votes
                      #12.3 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 11:10 AM EDT

                      I am disgusted by these parents. Instead of teaching their children about acceptance, they are teaching them how to discriminate against people who have circumstances beyond their control. I have four children and the fourth, a 1st grader, has severe, off the charts, never grow out of it peanut/tree nut allergies. Her classmates are not only very accepting, but they look out for her in the lunch room. Do these people who have their children on the picket lines not know what is going on in the world around us. Are they not thankful to be alive and living in a free country? God forbid their child should have to wash their hands one extra time in a day. If this is how they treat a 7 year old girl, I would hate to see how they treat a Veteran. Great parenting.....NOT!

                        #12.4 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 2:48 PM EDT

                        What kind of parent would send their child into such a potentially dangerous situation? She should be homeschooled. I agree with Confused parent-what if she DOES have a fatal reaction to an accidental exposure? Will the child who caused it be made to feed guilty?

                        I'm sorry, but having the children rinse out their mouths is going way too far. She should be homeschooled if it is that dangerous to her. I wouldn't take that chance with my children.

                        And I wish I could hear the same sympathy for ADHD children on here. Instead, a rambunctious child who is "interfering" with the other children's learning is drugged up.

                        Fifteen seconds is not enough time to properly clean one's hands. AT LEAST 20 seconds is requried.

                        • 1 vote
                        #12.5 - Sat Mar 26, 2011 12:40 PM EDT
                        Reply

                        whats really sad is ppl like you that want to sit back and say the kids with special needs cant go to school! they have rights just like the rest of the kids there. thats whats wrong with the kids today the parents tell their kids to treat the kids with special needs wrong! well im a parent of a kid with special needs and he goes to school everyday and i dare a parent to come in and say mine cant go to school. to tracey hold your head up and dont let them nuts run your lil girl out of school!!!!!!!

                        • 3 votes
                        Reply#13 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:25 AM EDT

                        The story about the girl with the peanut allergy & the other parents/students thinking it is not fair/right for the other children to have to wash their hands, wipe their face and not be allowed to have snacks with nuts, just makes me even more embarrassed to admit that I live in Fl. Like Ann Curry said "What happen to teaching children compassion?" If my children went to a school and they had to implement such rules, I would not have a problem with it. Children are not only learning at school, but they are also supposed to be safe their also. Feed your kids nuts at home. Wash your hands when you first get to class (after riding the bus with all of those germs) probably a good idea! Wipe your face, again big deal. All for the safety of a child...well worth it!!

                        • 2 votes
                        Reply#14 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:26 AM EDT

                        Funny, I thought the same thing. Why does it always have to be Florida? Makes me so sad. I am not sure who I feel worse for. The family of this child who most certainly do not need nor deserve this, or the kids who are learning very dangerous lessons about intolerance from their parents.

                        • 1 vote
                        #14.1 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:39 AM EDT

                        Yes, FL again. Didn't one of the sigsn say "Where is the median"...?

                        I live in Florida and my daughter has a peanut allergy. Its mild but it can get life threatening overnight the doctor says so we have to take precautions. The kids in my daughter's class wash their hands and don't bring in peanuts. There were some complaints but the school has been very supportive.

                        • 1 vote
                        #14.2 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:05 AM EDT

                        This is just another example of ignorance breeding ignorance. Parents should be teaching tolerance and compassion. Nothing will change if the adults do not teach these things to their children. As for the snacks, we need to teach our children healthy choices, apples, oranges, grapes, carrots, etc... these are all peanut free. By doing so we not only make a safer environment for all of our children , we help all of our children to be healthier. Hand washing is a non factor, or at least it should be, it is just good practice when you are in an environment with so many little people.

                        • 2 votes
                        #14.3 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:47 AM EDT

                        I am absoluelty greatful to all the parents going through this and putting it out there. I am a childcare teacher and mother of a 18 month old, my son had a allergic reaction to peanut butter sandwich when he was 7 months. It was given as a small pieces for a snack, he broke out in hives all over his face and body. Thank the lord it was not that severe as death. I have been so protective to the issue of food allergies. The fact is that any child and adult may get food allergies and we all must be acknowledge on it with respect. Whether its in your family or in the community, it is just as important like other medical conditions. Alot of you mentioned, that it is hard on the parent that has the child with the food allergy, when it comes to public places like restauraunts, grocery shopping and schools most definelty. I try to accomodate my son by keeping him away from nuts, or its allergin family. It is hard, we keep track of it all and are constantly checking labels on ingredients and making waiters at restauraunts aware that we have a child with peanut allergy. I just believe that the issue of taking more time to clean surfaces and washing hands is better for all. It lets the children understand the cause and effect of an issue. Alot of you hit the best part about good and healthly hygene. The whole issue is not a interruption, it is a great aid in learning. I want my son to attend school one day and not wearing protective gear like an outkast. So if all teachers, children and there parents can do alittle extra hand washing and get the facts before they argue an issue it would be reasonable. Then as a team to come up with solutions for all children to be safe and have equal oppourtunity to get a public education.

                        • 1 vote
                        #14.4 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 11:52 AM EDT

                        I am an elementary teacher. I have a peanut allergy. So do a few children in my class. It is simple. We don't allow snacks with peanuts in the classroom. You have to keep all of the children safe just as you would want to do with the teacher or any other adult. It is amazing how fast someone with a peanut allergy or any food allergy can get sick and die. The only savior is an epi pen. The students in my classroom know that if I get sick they have to page the nurse for an epi pen. How scary is that? To avoid it, we don't have peanuts in our classroom and there has not been a problem at all. We care about each other and it is that simple.

                        On a recent vacation--2 days ago, we had to fly. What do airlines serve? Peanuts. I called and asked what they could do for me. Nothing. They told me to change my flight to the first one of the day so there wouldn't be peanut dander. However, that didn't work for me. I was told to tell the stewardess not to serve peanuts which I did. I wiped down my entire area and took a double dose of medicine for a week to help build up against the peanuts in the air. That is not a way for a person to live. She forgot and start passing peanuts out the entire plane. I had to remind them of my allergy, they announced to the plane as I was standing in front, collected the peanuts, and I had to take a double dose allergy pills so I wouldn't get sick and stop breathing, have to use an epi pen while flying through the sky. That is a scary thought. This is exactly how the little girl in the classroom must feel each day. People on the plane were not happy, but that is how it goes. You have to deal with situation that you are presented with.

                        Food allergies are deadly--they are not like seasonal allergies. You cannot get a shot to help it go away. The only answer is to avoid the allergy. The little girl and her family are trying to do just that. At the age of 6 it is hard to understand the risk that you are taking. Parents of these families need to step up. So what if their child has to eat and apple without peanut butter for snack and wash their hands and mouth. If my child was in school, I would want him to wash his mouth and brush after lunch. It is proper hygiene. Washing hands cuts down on germs. We wash hands after snack daily. It doesn't take 30 minutes of your day. And if it does take 10 it is a life lesson. Do some of these parents realize that there are many adults who don't wash their hands after using the restroom. It is gross.

                        These children are learning so many lessons that are going to make them successful in life. Respect others. Be responsible by knowing what you can and cannot have at school. Be thankful it isn't you. Safety is important. Wash your hands before and after eating. Brush your teeth because we must take care of them.

                        What are the parents of some of these students teaching them?

                        Worry about yourself.

                        Don't care for others.

                        If you don't get you way throw a fit.

                        As a teacher....that is not what we want to see from our future. I think the school board should protect this family and what they are doing. Maybe the parents of other students should be thankful. It isn't their child they have to worry about dying from someone else's mistake.

                        Life is short. Enjoy it. Don't let something as simple as washing hands and mouth while taking away peanuts cause so much anger. Be thankful you have a teacher and a school who cares about a child so much. I bet you would want the same for you child. I know I would.

                          #14.5 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 1:50 PM EDT
                          Reply

                          As a woman who grew up BEFORE the Americans with disabilities act, I first want to applaud the school for trying so hard to accommodate the child... second, the parents for trying to give their child as normal a childhood as humanly possible and finally, NBC news for NOT putting the slant on it that these parents are wrong for insisting their child be treated fairly. I was also handicapped. Shunned in school, belittled, etc etc all because of a disability, not nearly as deadly as Little Girl Bailey's but bad enough! Personally I would home-school my child, just simply because I would not trust the other adults to do what they need to, but then she would miss out on socialization and friendships. So the "other parents" need to think about this... what if this were your child and he or she had to avoid dust... there is no doubt the school would accommodate them. So what is 45 second hand washing ritual, and 50 second mouth rinsing ritual? It does not add up to the exaggerated 30 minutes per day claimed by some. Pray about it and find the compassion you would want shown to your child!

                          • 2 votes
                          Reply#15 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:26 AM EDT

                          What is wrong with those people. We are talking about a childs life here. What does a little hand washing and mouth rinsing hurt. I bet that school had the lowest cold and flu year of any other school. I bet any one of the protesting parents would do anything to protect thier own child. They just sound like spoiled little children and they are not teaching thier own children anything. Grow up!! I'm sure if you asked the children, they don't mind helping out thier friend. Kids learn all this negative stuff from adults.

                          • 2 votes
                          Reply#16 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:26 AM EDT

                          What an ignorant statement, Susan, and what a missed opportunity to teach children about compassion by the parents spending time protesting instead of educating. If it were your child would you really want to stigmatize him/her by pulling them from their friends and their community to place in a special school. The lack of logic and common sense and shear selfishness of this comment and those of the parent interviewed are shocking. Our world is not in the best place, right now, and a little humanity could only help make the world a little better as caring children grow up to take over whatever there is left to take over. So sad. I hope and pray that this child lives a full life and is able to move past this and thrive in a community where she is supported. She is welcome at our child's public school any time.

                          • 2 votes
                          Reply#17 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:26 AM EDT

                          Parents need to step outside their box and educate themselves and their children. In the big scheme of things is it really a big deal? What if this was their child? As a mother of a child who suffers from food allergies, I can tell you that there is not a moment that goes by that I do not think about what my child is exposed to. As a parent you feel helpless and you can only hope those in your community have compassion for the situation.

                          As for the hand washing, kids should be washing their hands. It promotes healthy habits and has shown to reduce the cold and flu virus. Again, I urge parents who do not agree with this to think about the big picture and have compassion. These days kids are faced with so many things that are out of our control...take bullying for instance. Can't we all just think about others in this situation and be grateful that you do not have to live with it everyday of your life.

                          • 3 votes
                          Reply#18 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:28 AM EDT

                          The people in Florida have it all wrong. 30 minutes to wash hands....what about wipes in the classroom?? There are solutions! Instead of wasting time making signs for children to picket (what are we teaching them), why not teach them to problem solve and come up with solutions for their classmate. Where has our compassion gone?

                          • 2 votes
                          Reply#19 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:28 AM EDT

                           Seriously, peole are complaining about teaching tolerance for someone who is not the cookie cutter same as they are?  Extra handwashing and rinsing your mouth is bad because???  You might be preventing extra germs being passed around the classroom and reducing the amount of illnesses within the class.  Would be a great study to see if the extra hand washing does actually reduce germs.  For all those who say she should go to a special school that can deal with this, where is this place?  Tolerance, compassion, and differences are great and needed parts of education that are sorely lacking with these parents.

                          • 2 votes
                          Reply#20 - Thu Mar 24, 2011 8:28 AM EDT
                          Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 ... 9
                          You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                          As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.