Too posh to push? C-sections rise with social status

Are wealthy women too posh to push? A new British study shows that upper-class women are more likely to get elective C-sections, raising new questions about who get the surgery -- and why.

C-sections are the most frequently performed major surgery in the U.S., according to the International Cesarean Awareness Network. Around a third of U.S. pregnancies end with the operation, and in Britain, a quarter of babies make their entrance this way.

These facts don't sit well with the World Health Organization, which says C-sections should happen in no more than 5 percent to 15 percent of all deliveries.

What's going on? Researchers looked at 20 years of information on Scottish babies born via C-sections and the social class of their mothers -- 365,000 women in all. 

The data, published in the British journal BMC Public Health, showed that in the early 1980s, elective C-sections were mostly performed on women from lower socioeconomic classes. By the early 2000s, the findings were reversed: Upper-class women were more likely to have scheduled C-sections.

Some have dubbed this finding “Too Posh to Push,” but others don’t feel that’s the case.
 
Dr. Shari Lawson, obstetrician with Johns Hopkins Bayview Hospital, says the link between social class and rates of C-sections raises questions that the study doesn’t address. She suggests, “It might be that women who are from more affluent areas might also have more education and they’re asking their doctors more pointed questions that make an elective C-section the right thing for a particular patient.” 
 
Anyone who has ever recovered from a C-section, or knows a woman who has, clearly understands that major abdominal surgery is not a quick and easy way to opt out of the risks involved in pregnancy and labor.  Other reasons for more elective C-sections may include more women facing complications caused by advanced maternal age, obesity or high blood pressure.

We could certainly use more research to help understand why C-sections are performed and how to use that data to improve the outcomes for mom and baby, but the current report has one glaring omission.

There is no data kept on the reason given for the procedure.  Mom’s age, weight, length of pregnancy and even height were analyzed, but doctors didn’t collect data on the reasons given for having an elective C-section.

Maybe the best way to determine why more women are undergoing elective C-sections is simply to ask.

Tell us: Did you have a C-section, elective or emergency? What do you think of the latest research?

Jamila Bey is a journalist and speaker in Washington DC.

"Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

Discuss this post

Had an elective C-Section at age 31 in 2006. Recovery was very smooth for me. Home in 48 hours and normal routine again in a day or 2. Maybe I'm in the minority, but for me it was the only way to go.

    Reply#1 - Thu Feb 9, 2012 11:36 AM EST

    Why did you chose an elective C-Section over vaginal delivery? Just curious. Why was it the only way to go?

      #1.1 - Thu Feb 9, 2012 3:20 PM EST
      Reply

      I had an emergency c-section with my oldest, vbac'd the next 2 and had a scheduled with my twins. I felt great after the vbacs, the emergency c-section was very hard to recover from. The scheduled c-section was easier to recover from, but all told, I think pushing my kids out was by far the easiest on me and them. That is is just my opinion though.

        Reply#2 - Thu Feb 9, 2012 1:35 PM EST

        I can definitely believe this article. I come from a middle class Midwestern area and have heard many women my age (early twenties) say they wanted or were glad they had one because "they didn't want to f*** up their vagina". I also had a coworker tell me that even though it was easier and quicker to deliver in a squatting position, she would be to embarrassed to let her baby's father see her that way. A couple months later, she told the whole store that her sister had caught her having sex with him, drunk, on her mom and dads patio.

          Reply#3 - Sat Feb 11, 2012 2:56 AM EST

          I had a scheduled c-section due to complications which would make a normal birth impossible. My recovery was awful, every bit of 13 weeks, and I would never do it again. Major abdominal surgery is an accurate description.

            Reply#4 - Tue Feb 14, 2012 4:08 PM EST
            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.