Have you lied to your kids today?

Live Poll

Do you lie more or less often since you had kids?

View Results
  • 172817
    More often
    31%
  • 172818
    Less often
    42%
  • 172819
    About the same
    27%

VoteTotal Votes: 1021

Update: We asked TODAY Moms for some of your best -- or worst -- whoppers. Moms chimed in on our Facebook page to let us know that sometimes lying is unavoidable... and sometimes it's just hilarious.

Some of the lies our readers have told lately:

I told my 2 year old that if she didn't sit nicely in her booster seat that monsters would come eat her feet.

I always told my kids when they were little that when the ice cream truck was playing music it meant he was out of ice cream for the day

I have convinced my 3 year old that eating his "boogies" will cause him to grow worms in his mouth! He doesn't eat them anymore ~ and proudly proclaims it as well!!!!

Related from Parenting.com: Why lying's not so bad

Sometimes we lie to save ourselves aggravation. Yes, we know that we should straight-up tell our kids they can't have ice cream, but after a long day, a little white lie to prevent a temper tantrum seems forgivable.

Of course, sometimes moms lie about more serious things -- or to protect their children from harsh reality. One mom wrote on our Facebook page:

My son found our (stray, but we loved her) cat frozen, stuck in a fence. I told him that the vet saved and adopted it. He had just lost his biological mother the week before and another family member a few months before. He had enough death in his life. I hate to lie, but I couldn't break his heart.

The big debate over lying is how much is too much. And some moms think even little white lies are inexcusable, setting a bad example for our children:

TODAY Moms, I thought you were joking. Children copy the examples set by parents, & will eventually figure out if their parents are liars. Lying is not kindness -- it confuses a child about reality. I can usually explain the truth kindly & simply to a child (ran a licensed daycare), on their level--if (rarely) not, silence is an option.

What do you think? Read our original post, below, for more mommy lies and confessions.


 

Motherhood and lying -- they go together as naturally as motherhood and apple pie.

Of course, you know we didn't really bake that apple pie ourselves, right? Yeah, we bought it at the supermarket, threw out the plastic packaging and pretended it was home-made when we brought it to the bake sale.

We all know honesty is best, especially when it comes to setting a good example for our children. But a survey of 26,000 moms by TODAY Moms and Parenting.com found that a third admit to lying about their parenting practices.

And that doesn't count the lies we tell others, like the half of moms who say they've sent a sick child to school or day care (a lie of omission, if nothing else). And how about the whoppers we tell our kids? If you keep making that face, it'll freeze that way... Santa is totally watching you right now!

Related: Biggest Mom Confessions

Sometimes lies are innocent, even kind. It's OK to tell a friend that you can't get a baby-sitter instead of telling her you'd rather get a root canal than listen to her book club discuss Ann Coulter. It's fine to tell your husband that his new haircut totally doesn't make him look like Curly from the Three Stooges (it'll grow out). And it's sweet to reassure your child that you've sprayed extra-strength monster repellent in the closet and underneath the bed.

Live Poll

In the last week, have you lied to your children?

View Results
  • 172820
    Yes
    48%
  • 172821
    No
    52%

VoteTotal Votes: 579

Check out lies other moms tell. Here are some of the answers we got when we asked moms, anonymously, what their biggest parenting lie or secret is:

Live Poll

In the last week, have you lied to your spouse/partner?

View Results
  • 172822
    Yes
    28%
  • 172823
    No
    72%

VoteTotal Votes: 552

"My kid never does that..." trust me he has.  Mine will talk back, will tell you like it is and really doesn't care, and will call you out if you lie to him. Yeah, Mommy taught him that one...

"[Telling my kids] there's not more junk food/ice cream/chocolate" .... because I ate it or will be eating it. 

While I was pregnant with my second child and craving lots of sweets I told my 3 year old that Rice Krispie treats were spicy!  I did not want to share!

Live Poll

In the last week, have you lied to your friends?

View Results
  • 172826
    Yes
    25%
  • 172827
    No
    75%

VoteTotal Votes: 532

1. Told kids that I had eyes in the back of my head (when the kids were little they believed it because I always knew...) 2. Variation on a theme: we went away and left the teens at home and my husband told them we'd set up webcams. They tried to find them :-)

"I don't think it's on right now" when she wants to watch her favorite show on TV.

I claim that we are busy when I don't feel like hosting playdates... I'd rather that my kids just play with each other. Less stress with fewer kids in the house.

Live Poll

In the last week, have you lied to your boss/coworkers?

View Results
  • 172824
    Yes
    21%
  • 172825
    No
    79%

VoteTotal Votes: 473

Biggest Lie: That I can do it all. My house is a wreck, but I'm not going to prioritize cleaning over childcare, work, food, or sleep.

Biggest secret is probably that I do have a favorite child of the three. It's so stinkin' hard NOT to like him more!

I am known as a nutrition "freak" but there are nights that my husband is out of town when I park the kids at the TV. Then I go in the kitchen to make a dinner of popcorn (whole grains), jerky (lean protein), and grapes (fruit). Then I sit down in the kitchen & eat cheese & buttered popcorn & wine with a gossip mag.

Faking out the Stouffer's frozen macaroni and cheese in the Red Robin containers.  Our kids only eat Red Robin mac and cheese, but it's exactly the same as Stouffer's, so we kept the containers, boxes and bags from Red Robin, microwave the Stouffer's mac 'n cheese and then put it into the Red Robin containers.

What do you think: Is fibbing an inevitable part of motherhood? Do you embrace the occasional fiction... or worry about it? What's the "best" whopper you've told lately? Come clean here!

Getty Images stock

Really, mom? Eating brussel sprouts will turn me into a princess?

 

 

"Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

Discuss this post

Jump to discussion page: 1 2

My daughter was about 4 years old when she announced that her friend's Mom just had another baby and that her friend told her "it hurts really bad". She asked me if that was true and I told her it was. She asked how babies get into their Mom's bellies and I told her that Jesus puts them in there. She started to get kind of upset and said "But I don't want to have a baby if it hurts." I told her that was fine; she didn't have to have a baby if she didn't want to. "But what if Jesus puts one in my belly anyway?!?" She was very panicky at this point and I told her that there was actually something else you had to do with a boy before Jesus put a baby in there. "What?" I told her we'd talk about it when she was older. "No. Tell me now! What is it? Just tell me." I told her that it was kind of complicated and I could try to explain it to her but she wouldn't understand it until she was older. "No, Mama, please just tell me what it is because I want to make sure that I never do it!!!!" I finally just told her that it all starts with kissing and left it at that. "Okay, well I am NEVER going to kiss a boy."

  • 2 votes
Reply#1 - Mon Jan 9, 2012 11:38 AM EST

I really don't lie to my kids. I think it's better to be honest with them from the start. They're not really at the questioning phase, but when we get there I'll explain things as best I can, regardless of what the question is. When my kids want to watch a show I don't like or want a treat I don't tell them it's not on or that we don't have any. At 3 years and 20 months they're both too smart for that. My husband and I tell them honestly that we don't want to watch that show or that they just can't have a treat right then.

    Reply#2 - Mon Jan 9, 2012 4:29 PM EST

    They're just white lies, to get your child to eat his food and curb bad behavior, I wouldn't call it "lying" considering no one is getting hurt and all parents do it at some point.

      Reply#3 - Mon Jan 9, 2012 4:30 PM EST

      white lies are still lies. At what point do you stop telling these little white lies. Being honest with your children is absolutely the best policy. And if the answer is we're not going to talk about that right now or it's an inappropriate conversation for your age. And the lady in green on the show this morning talking about telling your child the park is closing we have to go. That's absurd, if you can't get 10 minutes ahead of the child and prepare them for leaving any place. Well, that's just lazy. Preparing your child to leave a fun place starts when they're able to walk. If you start lying then, well I just can't help.

      \

        #3.1 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 9:38 AM EST
        Reply

        You lie to your children, you breed LIARS. You are rude in front of your children, you breed rude people. You talk crap about others, you breed gossipers and bullies. GET THE PICTURE MOMMIES!

          Reply#4 - Mon Jan 9, 2012 6:08 PM EST

          On your side Kaylin

            #4.1 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 9:47 AM EST
            Reply

            Please, please, please stop saying over and over that moms lie to their kids about certain childhood fantasies! It is 8 am. There could be kids watching. You both could have left it at "childhood fantasies." The whole world knew what you were talking about as the whole world helps to perpetuate it!

            • 1 vote
            Reply#5 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:28 AM EST

            Right on madmeg! My son was watching. That is exactly what I wanted to say. Oh and thanks for ruining all the "childhood fantasies" we still had left Today, and your so called expert! At least the segment didn't air before Christmas. You killed Santa.

              #5.1 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 9:14 AM EST
              Reply

              The "professionals" who appeared on Wed am's today show made some preposterous proposals. The statement (I'm paraphrasing") "If you need to leave the park because you have another obligation and the kids don't want to go, it's okay to say you have to go because the park is closing," is the laziest, stupidest thing I've ever heard. The kid needs to leave the park because you said so. Period. Whining and crying? Give em something to cry about - like a swat on the behind with a wooden spoon. So, when your kid is 16 and 6'2 and you are confronting them about a lie, keep in mind, they learned it from you. Little white lies and regular black lies are ALL lies. If the truth is inconvenient, that's just life.

                Reply#6 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:30 AM EST

                Don't necessarily agree. My son would get into a debate about the why we needed to leave if I didn't say something as concrete as "the park was closing." Trying the "we need to go because ..." tactic, while the truth, just started a discussion, which is not what was needed with a four-year-old. My teenagers now actually find it amusing that I use to tell them we didn't get certain programs on our TV because I didn't want them to watch them. Now I tell them why they can't do something and they deal with consequences because they understand them, and because the stakes are higher and have more meaning to them.

                  #6.1 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:19 AM EST

                  That's really nice that your teenagers find it amusing that you lied to them. I guess you'll probably be amused too when they lie to your grandchildren. It's always nice to have something passed down through the family that you can take pride in.

                  UNBELIEVABLE!!!

                    #6.2 - Thu Jan 12, 2012 3:34 PM EST
                    Reply

                    I was completely shocked someone would believe to lie to your kids is ok. We even told our kids Santa is a fun story and we can enjoy it, but Jesus was born at Christmas and that's what we celebrate. They are very stable kids and know Mom and Dad are not going to lie to them. My husband grew up where lying was everyday and he felt a lot of resentment toward them. Can we not trust our kids to handle truth properly?

                      Reply#7 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:36 AM EST

                      We think alike!

                        #7.1 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:44 AM EST
                        Reply

                        WOW!! In less than a 5 minute interview, these ladies---#1: completely ruined the "fantasies of childhood" by dispelling Santa, Easter Bunny,Tooth Fairy,etc., to any small child that happened to be in the room while the Today show was on.... #2 Essentially said, because Moms are under pressure, that it's "ok" to lie, and #3 even if the child finds out about the "lie", it's ok, because you still have time to "repair" your relationship.......REALLY??????!!! Damaging interview in too many ways.....geeze.

                          Reply#8 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:40 AM EST

                          I agree!!! I couldn't believe that this interview aired....and what upset me the most is that my KIDS (ages 7, 4 and 2) were playing and getting ready for school while I kept an ear out for the weather and got their belongings ready...Within moments my 7 yr old ran into the room and said 'Mom's lie!!! And the Today Show said mom's lie about Santa and the Easter Bunny and Tooth Fairy!" I was so upset! Thanks for nothing Today show!!! I have been a loyal viewer for years, but this segment really upset me and I will certainly not have this show on in the background in the AM. You think the producers could have prepped the guests/Ann Curry before airing?!?! A simple, watch what you say b/c kids are still home and might be watching this...Really really disappointed that I know have to back peddle and LIE to get my child to not question something he loves so much such as Santa, etc.

                            #8.1 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 1:35 PM EST
                            Reply

                            I'm dismayed to see that lying is considered okay at anytime. I do not lie to my kids, not about Santa, not about anything. I don't lie to my husband or friends either. If I realize that I did, I apologize! I want them to love the truth whatever that may be and not be wondering if they can trust me. Lying builds distrust and is a form of disrespect.

                              Reply#9 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:41 AM EST

                              I completely agree with kaylin76 i DO NOT lie to my kids!!! That is probably the most important thing I want to teach my kids, to BE HONEST! Yes, this might step on people's toes, but I am teaching them that words are powerful and also teaching them to speak appropriately and kindly. Since I don't lie, we do not have Santa, Easter Bunny, Tooth Fairy in our house. The featured guest on the show gave the example of being at the park and saying if it was time to go it was okay to say "the park is closed" to avoid a big scene. ARE YOU KIDDING ME?! Step up and BE THE PARENT! It's umcomfortable and hard and your kids will not like a lot of the decision you make. But guess what.....that's why YOU are in charge and NOT them. If it's time to go, IT'S TIME TO GO. If your kids throw a fit, physically pick them up and place them in the car and they will receive the appropriate consequences at home. I feel very passionate about this since we are raising a generation of pacified, entitled children whose parents are afraid to "hurt their feelings." I love my children more than anybody, but I feel I am not doing them any favors by making sure they always "feel good" by tiptoeing around the truth, or by flat-out LYING.

                              • 1 vote
                              Reply#10 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:44 AM EST

                              I just saw this segment on the Today Show and was a little worked up about it. Are you kidding me? It's okay to lie to your child because you have a full schedule and the car is parked a 1/2 mile away? Plan ahead, ladies! How hard is it to give your child a 5 or 10 minute warning? And it's okay to lie to your child because you need to keep up with the technology of the day, e.g. Facebook and Twitter? Did I hear that correctly? Whether you call it a lie or a white lie, I think it's a cop out. I heard a woman in a store tell her little girl that if she didn't sit correctly and quietly in the shopping cart, the police would come. There are so many other ways to parent that are honest and, frankly, much more effective.

                              (coming from a mother of four children, ages 10, 13, 16 & 18)

                                Reply#11 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:48 AM EST

                                Ok...I'm watching the Today show and they are doing a segment on Mom's lying to their kids. This woman is actually saying that lies (small) are necessary. First off, a lie is lie no matter the size or color. Second, they are never necessary but rather a choice because you can't think of any other way to handle the situation without dealing with the possibility of guilty feelings. I have a teen that I've NEVER lied to nor do I need to do so. If it's something I don't want him to know (for whatever reason), I tell him it's not for him to know. Otherwise, I tell him in an age appropriate way. The best part is: My conscience is free of guilt.

                                  Reply#12 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:52 AM EST

                                  Shame on the Today show for allowing specific examples of childhood stories to be used as examples of parent lies. Many families have the Today show on as they are preparing for their day, this includes children. The content of the interview could have been understood by the viewers without using these examples by name. It is a decision of the parents, not the Today Show, to reveal truths or keep the magic of these childhood characters alive in their homes.

                                    Reply#13 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 9:14 AM EST

                                    I am outraged. Not only did this story make me sick so did the "experts" you had speaking on the topic. Being a parent means teaching your children the good and bad about life. Sometime these things are fun to teach and other times it hurts or may be uncomfortable. We are raising future adults here people. Too often I am encountered by an adult that was raised by a lieing parent and am offended by their behavior. Let's look at the facts and start being honest with ourselves. Maybe, just maybe if we teach our children honesty from the begining we wont have to hear of cheating spouses, bank robbers/kidnappers trying to get away with, well, robbery and kidnapping, polititians that actually stand for what they say they believe in (streching I know) and so on. I do celebrate the Santa tradition in my home second the the celebration of the birth of Jesus. Santa, also known as Chris Kringle, was a real man and gave gifts to children to celebrate the love he experienced and carry on the giving of Christ (simply stated). I give one gift to my children from "Santa" and carry on that tradition, and they know this. As for leaving the park or not going someplace they would rather be, never lie it will backfire some home eventually and the only ting that will do is discredit you. Food for thought when you think of the teenagers that hate their parents.

                                      Reply#14 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 9:17 AM EST

                                      There's nothing wrong with telling white lies to your kids to get to curb their bad behavior. When I was a child my brother & I were very picky about eating vegetables so my mom pointed out an elderly woman with severe osteoporosis while we were at the grocery store & told us she got that way because she didn't eat her vegetables! While that's not really the truth, it got my brother & I to eat our veggies without anymore complaining & now that I'm an adult I know that she was fibbing, but I don't think any of my mom's fibs hurt me or confused me in any way. As long as you're honest about the things that are important, little fibs won't even be remembered into adulthood.

                                      • 1 vote
                                      Reply#15 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 9:17 AM EST

                                      I think the whole idea of lying to children being okay is ridiculous. You cannot expect to foster a culture of honesty between you and your kids when you lie to them. They will find out if they haven't already, and it will affect their ability to trust you at some point in the future. Our kids have never believed in Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny, because they would eventually learn the truth and be upset about it. When Santa, who is attributed with certain god-like powers, is shown to be a well-spun fallacy later in a kids life, it can shake their belief in other things that are unseen. If you are a religious family, it could very well shake your kid's confidence in the existence of God. We have borne out a policy of honesty in our family and I believe our kids are better for it, and would tell you that themselves.

                                        Reply#16 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 9:33 AM EST

                                        I don't call celebrating the magic of Santa, the Easter bunny, or tooth fairy..lying. Its a part of being a kid and i choose to keep these characters alive for my son. As my parents did for me...there is no harm in believing. I do not condone lying about stupid things like "the park is closing" NO..you have other things to do and its time to go...enough said.

                                        • 1 vote
                                        Reply#17 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 9:48 AM EST

                                        My kids just came to me and told me Santa, The Easter Bunny and the tooth fairy aren't real because sometimes parents lie to their kids!!! and they heard it on the today show!!! Unbelievable, I guess my loyalty to this program is now over.

                                          Reply#18 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:27 AM EST

                                          I agree!! I was in the same boat. And thanks to the Today Show I had to LIE to keep them from being devastated by learning/hearing that is no such thing! Shame on you Today show! What we decide to do in our own homes/families for our is our business. Stay the heck out of it! I am shocked at the judgmental tone this segment had and SHOCKED that these people felt it was OKAY to say the truth about Santa etc. while kids were still home and watching!

                                            #18.1 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 1:41 PM EST
                                            Reply

                                            There is a huge difference between telling a story and out right Lying. If we tell our children a story about Santa and allow them to form their own opinion (eventually) it's no different then telling them a story about Noah and the Ark, or Daniel and the Lions den...it's a personal, parental choice and certainly not harmful. I also do not agree that explaining something to a child on the level they are able to understand it is lying. Like telling my child semen is the seed that makes babies...(it was on the Nature Channel, don't judge!) That wasn't lying, it was filtering the truth for his age & understanding.

                                            And by the way...what is wrong with saying brussel sprouts are baby cabbages if it gets my kids to eat them?! PUHLEASE!

                                            • 1 vote
                                            Reply#19 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:33 AM EST

                                            I am an avid Today show viewer and although I do monitor which segments I watch while my kids are in the room, I was not prepared for what I saw during this segment. From what I gather looking at the rest of these comments the women from Parenting magazine were defending lying to your children. I did not make it that far into the segment because I quickly raced to turn the Tv off when I heard the woman being interviewed comment that Santa and the Tooth Fairy are among the lies we tell our kids. I am so disappointed that on a morning tv show, this woman would not have enough common sense to think before she opened her mouth. Isn't there an unwritten rule about this type of behavior???

                                              Reply#20 - Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:40 AM EST
                                              Jump to discussion page: 1 2
                                              You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                              As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.