• MSN
  • Hotmail
  • More
    • Autos
    • My MSN
    • Video
    • Careers & Jobs
    • Personals
    • Weather
    • Delish
    • Quotes
    • White Pages
    • Games
    • Real Estate
    • Wonderwall
    • Horoscopes
    • Shopping
    • Yellow Pages
    • Local Edition
    • Traffic
    • Feedback
    • Maps & Directions
    • Travel
    • Full MSN Index
  • Bing
  • msnbc.com sites & shows:
  • TODAY
  • Rock Center
  • Nightly News
  • Meet the Press
  • Dateline
  • Morning Joe
  • Hardball
  • Ed
  • Maddow
  • The Last Word
  • msnbc tv
  • People
  • Entertainment
  • Food
  • Health
  • Money
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Pets
  • Parenting
  • Style
  • KLG & Hoda
  • Blogs
    • allDAY
    • Animal Tracks
    • Bites
    • The Clicker
    • Digital Life
    • Hip2Save
    • Kathie Lee & Hoda
    • Life Inc.
    • The Look
    • Scoop
    • TODAY Entertainment
    • TODAY Health
    • TODAY Moms
    • TODAY Travel
  • More
    • Comics & Games
    • Concert Series
    • Good News!
    • Horoscope
    • Lotto
    • News
    • Photo Features
    • Relationships
    • The Royals
    • Tech
    • TODAY at 60
    • Weather
    • Weddings
  • Recommended: Help Natalie Morales with her boys' bedtime routines!
  • Recommended: My little Linus: In defense of security blankets
  • Recommended: Parent confession: Many skip booster seats for carpoolers
  • Recommended: Homeless dad's message of hope: 'Never give up'
Learn, share and discuss at TODAY Moms: parenting news and views from TODAY, top headlines and you. We're all in this together, so join the conversation.
  • ↓ About this blog
  • ↓ Archives
    • Icons Email E-mail updates
      You are subscribed.
      change this
      ()
      Loading Saving...
    • Icons Twitter Follow on Twitter
    • Icons Feed Subscribe to RSS
  • advertisement
    17
    Nov
    2011
    8:00am, EST

    Taming temper tantrums: Are you doing it wrong?

    By Rebecca Dube

    Research shows that 70 percent of children throw temper tantrums, according to parenting expert Michele Borba.

    Wait, what? Who are these 30 percent of calm children, and where can I get one?

    Live Poll

    How often does your child have temper tantrums? (Or how often did they, when they were younger?)

    View Results
    • 168020
      Often
      34%
    • 168021
      Sometimes
      51%
    • 168022
      Never
      15%

    VoteTotal Votes: 618

    Just kidding – like most parents, I’ve accepted that the occasional tantrum is going to be a kicking, screaming, brain-jarring pothole on the road to maturity.

    But researchers from Yale University and Kings College in the U.K. have been hard at work studying tantrums, and they say taming them is possible. It's all about proper training – for the parents, not the children.

    "Hold those sticker charts, fancy point systems and our pleads and threats. Those techniques are largely ineffective in changing kid behavior for the long haul," Borba says. In fact, experts say, most of the tried-and-true techniques taught by books are totally wrong.

    How parents react, before, during and after a tantrum, makes all the difference. Borba has lots of good, research-based advice for how to prevent tantrums. In the middle of one, though, it’s all about NOT reacting. Make sure your child is safe – that he is not going to flail himself into any sharp edges, for instance – and then ignore, ignore, ignore. Any attention you give a tantrum (even if it’s negative, like yelling), just reinforces children’s belief that the behavior is working because they’re getting attention for it. And trying to reason with a tantruming child mid-freakout “is like trying to reason with a goldfish,” Borba says. The real key to killing off tantrums? Praising the behavior you want to see, coupled with an encouraging touch like a hug or high-five.

    When are tantrums not normal? If your child is in danger or hurting herself or others, or if he’s having intense tantrums daily, seek some outside help. A larger behavioral or emotional issue could be the cause.

    What’s your best tantrum-taming tactic?

    Follow Michele Borba on Twitter @micheleborba.

    Rebecca Dube is TODAY Moms editor and mom of a feisty 2-year-old who was recently outraged to learn that cookies are not for breakfast.

    "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

    12 comments, including:

    I am completely in awe that this is considered 'new' research! In all of my life, this is all I have ever known...since being a young aunt to now having my 5 children.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: borba, discipline, tantrum, showfront
  • 5
    Aug
    2011
    8:58am, EDT

    Decoding temper tantrums (the kind Mom and Dad throw)

    By Lela Davidson

    It’s not so bad when babies cry. We know they’re just doing it to get basic needs met.  We realize we committed to 3 a.m. lullabies and perpetual feeding, and years of diaper duty. We don’t mind, much, but once they can talk, shouldn’t our children express their needs in rational tones? Are complete sentences too much to ask?

    The science of meltdowns
    Fully functional toddlers continue to cry, and add whining, screaming, and destruction to their catalog of exasperating behaviors. On the bright side, these tantrums give us scientific insight into the human condition. 

    Live Poll

    Which is the worst part of a temper tantrum (the kid kind)?

    View Results
    • 155753
      The whining
      34%
    • 155754
      The screaming
      41%
    • 155755
      The full-body thrashing
      26%

    VoteTotal Votes: 2190

    In a recent study, researchers at the University of Connecticut—who presumably did not have a raging child nearby—analyzed the acoustic features of temper tantrums. Yes, they listened. Findings included:

    • Distinct characteristics of tantrum sounds can be categorized into the following: screaming, yelling, crying, whining, and fussing.
    • The above correlated to two basic emotions: mad and sad.
    • Intensity levels of the typical toddler meltdown varied over the duration of the tantrum, and with the intensity of emotion.

    (I could have told them that.)

    Related link: Get your toddler's meltdowns under control

    Parents, where's our study?
    Scientists believe this research provides valuable information about how we express and regulate strong emotions. Maybe, but I think they studied the wrong subjects. We may learn more about emotional responses by studying the parents’ emotional state, which includes more complex feelings and also escalates over the course of an “attack.” For example:

    • Parents who respond calmly and immediately to a toddler’s demands are often CONCERNED, whereas those observed picking up pretzels from the kitchen floor for the fourth time today show signs of IRRITATION.
    • Dissolving into a puddle of tears on the kitchen floor because a 2-year-old—in a fit of super-human proportions—has hurled creamed spinach onto the white carpet two rooms away, may indicate that the subject is SAD.
    • Rolling of the eyes is often associated with SUSPICION that child in question is not actually “thirsty” but simply practicing manipulation techniques crucial for later years when he “needs” an iTouch.
    • During a tantrum, a rise in blood pressure, heartbeat, and mild sweating can be outward signs of FEAR, perhaps that you will succumb to the urge to trade your screaming child to nearest traveling carnival for two packs of smokes and an oversized plush toy.
    • Dropping an F-Bomb almost always signals that a parent is ANGRY. While this particular manifestation is usually followed by expressions of REMORSE, parents can only take so much. Seriously—what part of “yogurt all gone” do they not understand?

    Fortunately, every tantrum sooner (God willing) or later comes to an end. At this time certain facial expressions observed after the second glass of wine are associated with ECSTACY. Trust me on this. I got my PhD in the Pediatric Academy of Two-Under-Two.

    What are your emotional responses to the temper of your toddler, and how do you regulate them?

    For more from TODAY Moms on the crazy world of parenting, check out these links:
    How to tell if your baby is a super-genius
    Stop the royal womb-watching madness!
    Cherish every moment? Yeah sure, whatever

    Lela Davidson is the author of Blacklisted from the PTA (Jupiter Press, imprint of Wyatt-MacKenzie, July 2011). Her writing is featured regularly in family and parenting magazines throughout the United States and Canada. She blogs about marriage, motherhood, and life-after-40 at After the Bubbly.

    "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

    Leave your comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: discipline, featured, showfront
  • 10
    Dec
    2010
    12:21pm, EST

    The perils of rewards

    From Positive Parenting Solutions founder and TODAY Moms contributor, Amy McCready

    Let’s admit it: some days it seems like our greatest challenges as parents aren’t the sleepless nights or busy carpool schedules—it’s getting our kids to do what we want them to do. Understandably, many of us resort to using rewards, whether we’re offering a cookie to any child who cleans her plate or promising concert tickets for good grades.

    But it’s not just parents who use rewards to motivate good behavior or minimize negative behavior—we also see stickers in the doctor’s office, lollipops at the bank, and for grown-ups, punch cards at our local coffee shop.

    “We dangle goodies (from candy bars to sales commissions) in front of people in the same way that we train the family pet,” aptly comments Alfie Kohn in his book, "Punished by Rewards."

    Unfortunately, what would seem like a great strategy for coaxing little ones to behave actually falls flat.

    In the New York Times Best Selling book "DRIVE – The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us," author Daniel Pink shares The Seven Deadly Flaws of Carrots (Rewards) and Sticks (Punishment).  According to Daniel Pink, 50 years of behavioral research proves that “carrots and sticks” can extinguish intrinsic motivation; diminish performance; crush creativity; crowd out good behavior; encourage cheating, shortcuts, and unethical behavior; become addictive and foster short-term thinking.

    Ouch! Why is this? For one, by offering rewards we let our kids know that we lack confidence in their willingness or ability to behave or perform a task without a reward. And when used consistently, rewards become a means to an end so that children will never tinkle in the potty or empty the dishwasher without the promise of a treat.

    What’s more, rewards offer external motivation rather than internal motivation. They may seem like an easy “fix” in the short-term, but over time they lose their luster and also erode a child’s sense of personal satisfaction in such things as reading a book, learning to play piano or being kind to a little sibling.

    In fact, a growing body of research shows that rewards actually diminish a child’s interest in the desired behavior: the more that “desirable” behaviors are rewarded, the less interest children show in whatever they are being bribed to do.  Children who were once intrinsically motivated to do something eventually lost interest in those tasks in which an external reward was offered. Instead of intrinsic satisfaction that comes from accomplishing something new or seeing the smile on a sibling’s face, the behavior is associated with the external reward, or the “goodie.”

    Why is this important? While external motivation would leave our kids relying on rewards for good deeds or constant praise, internal motivation will successfully guide them through the years to come—with school, careers and relationships.

    So, how do you get your kids to do what you want them to, without using rewards?

    For starters, you develop their sense of internal motivation by using training, encouragement and consequences.

    1. Take time For training. Make it a priority to fully teach your kids the appropriate behavior, or the right way to complete a task. Not only will they get a huge boost of pride in their new accomplishment, they’ll also be more likely to do the right thing in the future. 
    2. Use encouragement. Encourage your kids by letting them know that their contributions make a difference, or that you notice their growing independence. For instance, you can say “Wow, I used to have to help you on the potty and now you’re doing it all by yourself!” or “Thanks for emptying the dishwasher—now all the dishes are ready for supper!” or “Your hard work has really improved your math skills this semester!”
    3. Employ consequences when necessary. Of course, kids will still misbehave from time to time, and if they do you can implement fair and effective consequences to help them understand the real effects of negative behavior.

    By focusing on training and encouragement and using consequences for poor choices, you can avoid relying on rewards when addressing your kids’ behavior. In doing so, you’ll develop the internal motivation that will lead to success throughout their lives.

    Amy McCready is the founder of Positive Parenting Solutions and mom to two boys, ages 12 and 15. Positive Parenting Solutions teaches parents of toddlers to teens how to correct misbehaviors without nagging, reminding or yelling. For free discipline training resources, visit: www.PositiveParentingSolutions.com

     

    "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

    6 comments, including:

    I found out the hard way how difficult of a habit this can be to break.  I used to give my daughter "special treats" if she was good in tough situations.  For example, if we had a big day of errands and she made it through without whining, begging for things and was just an overall good girl, she  …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: discipline, rewards
  • 15
    Nov
    2010
    10:22am, EST

    'Twilight' town's teens penalized for punky protest

    AP

    Somewhere, Sid Vicious is snickering. Who'd have thought that almost three and a half decades since Britain's preeminent punk rock band, The Sex Pistols, first reared their spiky scalps and coughed up a viscous gob of phlegm at the world, they could still spark any semblance of controversy? Well, for a group of students in the small town of Forks, Wash. (an infamous burg already beset by hordes of obsessed teen vampire devotees for being the epicenter of all things “Twilight”), the very name “Sex Pistols” has proved to still pack the power to offend.

    After a student was instructed to remove a Sex Pistols T-shirt by a Forks High School official, former student body president Devon Chastain donned the offending garment herself and refused to take it off. As a result, she was sent home. The incident sparked a punky domino effect of sorts, as nine other students then staged a protest in front of the school in support of their suspended classmate, distributing more T-shirts bearing the Sex Pistols’ fabled ransom-note logo. In turn, these students were also suspended.

    In their defense, Forks High School officials cite that the student handbook expressly prohibits wearing clothing bearing sexual connotations. One might have imagined that the prurient interpretation of the band’s moniker would have been somewhat defanged in the past three decades of being emblazoned on T-shirts available at shopping malls around the world (also available in toddler sizes). Trainspotting apologists could also point out that late Sex Pistols’ manager Malcolm McLaren coined the band’s name to make them sound like “sexy young assassins,” and not necessarily as a lascivious innuendo, but that’s all rather academic.

    Parents, how would you feel if your child was sent home from school for wearing a Sex Pistols T-shirt? Are the folks in Forks maybe just a bit too sensitive in the wake of “Twilight” hysteria? Are these suspensions justifiable discipline or much ado about nothing? Share your thoughts in the comments section.

    "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

    48 comments, including:

    How many friends did I have who wore those shirts in high school? If we don't let kids have some form of acceptable rebellion (and I think we can all agree it could be much worse than a punk band tshirt) they will find another way to let us know they are individuals.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: teens, discipline, featured
  • 4
    Nov
    2010
    11:56am, EDT

    Fourth-grader's backpack too sexy for school?

    Pasco County School District

    UPDATE: The backpack brouhaha is over. Nine-year-old Quentin Ferrer decided to bring a different backpack to school on Thursday, after the racy illustration on his old backpack stirred up controversy. "He said, 'I felt uncomfortable at school,' " Fred Ferrer, Quentin's dad, told The St. Petersburg Times. "He said, 'I don't want you to get in trouble.' So we went out and bought two new backpacks."

    Quentin Ferrer’s backpack isn’t your standard L.L. Bean model: The 9-year-old’s bag sports an illustration of a buxom, bikini-clad woman drawn in the style of a classic tattoo. The fourth-grader has been carrying it to school for two years, but another parent recently noticed the racy illustration and complained. The principal of Richey Elementary, north of Tampa, Fla., told Quentin to leave the backpack at home. But the boy’s father, Fred Ferrer, refused, saying the picture isn’t pornographic and doesn’t show drugs, weapons or violence. The principal compromised by allowing the boy to bring the backpack to school, but leave it in his office during the day. Fred Ferrer tells Tampa Bay Online he thinks that’s unacceptable, and threatened to dress his son in similarly styled shirts to make his point.

    What do you think? Was the principal right? Is this backpack too racy for elementary school?

    "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

    904 comments, including:

       The backpack should have been banned long ago.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: school, discipline, featured
  • 1
    Nov
    2010
    4:12pm, EDT

    Child sued over bike crash that hurt elderly woman

    How young is too young to be sued? How about 4 years old?

    A judge in New York recently ruled that a young girl can be sued for negligence after a 2009 accident: According to the lawsuit, two four-year-olds were racing their bicycles on a busy New York City street, while their mothers supervised, when they hit an 87-year-old woman named Claire Menaugh. She broke her hip and required surgery, and died three months later of unrelated causes.

    Menaugh’s estate sued both the mothers and their children for negligence. One of the families tried to have their child dismissed from the litigation, claiming she was too young to be sued – noting that her bike still had training wheels. But Justice Paul Wooten of the State Supreme Court in Manhattan ruled otherwise, writing that anyone older than 4 is legal fair game.

    According to The New York Times, the judge wrote there was no evidence that the 4-year-old defendant lacked “intelligence of maturity” and said that any “reasonably prudent child” would know not to engage in risky behavior with or without a parent present.

    Do you have a “reasonably prudent” 4-year-old? Do you think children should be held liable for bike-riding accidents, or their parents --  or no one at all? Share your thoughts in the comments section below.

    "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

    23 comments, including:

    Not rule that can't be bent...I really know those 2 kids planed to knock that lady down.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: discipline
  • 1
    Nov
    2010
    3:28pm, EDT

    11-year-old gets detention for breaking wind on school bus

    Let’s face it, everyone does it. While deemed inappropriate, inconsiderate and frankly disgusting in many circles of society, sooner or later, everyone passes gas. It’s simply an avoidable fact of life.  

    But for a one sixth grader in Parma, Ohio, it’s a fact of life that landed him in trouble.  Last week, Christian Summers, 11, was punished with serving an hour of detention at Thoreau Park Elementary School after he repeatedly farted on the school bus. Some might have found it amusing (arguably Summers himself), but the bus driver didn’t.

    According to school officials, Summers is a repeat offender, but is the act of breaking wind really a crime worthy of this brand of discipline? Parents, do you think this boy was punished unfairly, or was the school justified in its action? Are the boy's actions symptomatic of a larger cultural problem? Share your thoughts in the comment section.

    "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

    3 comments, including:

    We don't get all the facts with this article. Does he have a medical condition like IBS? If so he might not have been able to help it. If this is the case he shouldn't have gotten detention.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: discipline
  • 26
    Jul
    2010
    11:20am, EDT

    Is it OK to discipline other people's children?

    By TODAYshow.com contributor and "Ask Kitty" columnist, Kitty Schindler

    In a column last year, I wrote about growing up in a small town where children were everyone's concern. "Spare the rod and spoil the child" seemed to be universally accepted, which meant that friends, neighbors and relatives all could (and did) involve themselves how we kids behaved.

    Today’s moms and dads are often better educated in parenting than mine were. Even so, many are uncertain about how to discipline their own children, much less the children of others. Do we live in such a “mind your own business” world that we are afraid to speak out when we see others’ children – or their parents -- misbehave?

    Say you see a mother whose child is acting up in a store administer a slap on the bottom. That's fine with me, if it's moderate; if it's child abuse, it’s an entirely different situation. But let’s say the mother does nothing to correct a child who is obviously misbehaving: Should you intervene?

    Unless someone is being endangered, probably not. Getting involved might only make the situation worse, for both child and mother. Still, if you see a small child trying to clamber out of a shopping cart while the mother isn't looking, there’s nothing wrong with telling the child, in a calm, friendly voice, to sit down -- or to alert the mother in the same modulated tone. Helping keep a child safe is always appropriate, regardless of whose it is. (And it's a lot better than helping to pick the child up off the floor.)

    But when the child is older, our scenario becomes more complex. Some older children nowadays won't listen to their own parents, let alone you. And if an outsider intervenes, the parents often defend the bad behavior of the child. That’s what makes life so difficult for schoolteachers these days, and why discipline in schools is so often a problem.

    Granted, there are many more influences on older children today than when I was growing up: TV, movies, rap music, social networking, texting and celebrity misbehavior, to name just a few. Bad examples can contribute to anti-social behavior. Bullying, taunting, teasing and the like are almost epidemic among older children, and have had tragic consequences.

    But there are things a parent can do. When other children came to my home to play with my kids, they had to obey the rules of the house. It was my house, and if I was to be responsible for them, they had to follow my rules.

    If someone didn't, he or she got one warning, and that usually was all it took. And when we got a swimming pool, there were even stricter rules. Anyone who disobeyed was sent home; no second chance.

    I know that some of my children’s friends thought I was pretty strict when I took games away from them or even sent a couple home. But it was pretty easy to maintain order, because everyone knew my rules and for the most part didn't object.

    My kids are all grown up now, but when my retired husband did some substitute teaching recently, he maintained classroom discipline in much the same way. Every student was told the rules every day, and the first to violate them was sent to the principal’s office. The others realized misbehavior wasn’t going to be tolerated, and for the rest of the day his classes were peaceful and productive. Children of almost any age will accept rules and discipline if those rules are enforced. If they aren’t, what good are they?

    Today’s world is a lot different than the little town I grew up in, where everyone pretty much agreed on the ground rules. These days, if you’re not the one in charge – in your own home or classroom, for example – it’s wise to mind your own business unless a situation requires more.

    But if it does, don’t be afraid to act accordingly. Times may have changed, but if I saw a child behaving recklessly, endangering himself or others, I would do whatever I thought necessary to eliminate the risk.

    Video: Tips to dole out discipline to another parent's child

    What do you think? Is it OK to discipline other people's children?

    Results with 33 short comments
    Total of 2,126 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

    28%
    Yes. After all, it takes a village to raise a child.
    596 votes
    16%
    No. Different parents have different styles; it's better to mind your own business.
    340 votes
    56%
    I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.
    1,190 votes
    Display Comments:
    Yes. After all, it takes a village to raise a child.

    Caught my daughters 5th grade friend stealing from my mother and spanked her 3 times on the bottom. Then called her mother and told her.

    • 4 votes
    #1
     - C's Mom
     - 11:42 am EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
    No. Different parents have different styles; it's better to mind your own business.

    You may think a child is misbehaving only to find out they have Autism. these parents have to explain to people over and over .

    • 3 votes
    #2
     - luvden
     - 12:53 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
    I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

    Worked in the school system & hands are tied to a point. But my house, my rules, & everyone knows/agrees in advance or they don't come over

    • 2 votes
    #3
     - pbgroupie
     - 1:27 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
    I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

    I corrected a BADLY misbehaving child and his father barked at me. Never again, unless the kid is fixing to jump off a 20 story building!

    • 1 vote
    #4
     - YVONNE-2021469
     - 3:11 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
    I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

    I intervened once when I saw a teen mom about to give honey to her baby. She didn't know it could harm her, and she thanked me profusely.

    • 1 vote
    #5
     - FluffyPinkKitten
     - 3:25 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
    I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

    It depends on the situation and the child. I think it's especially important to consider special needs children and parents.

    • 2 votes
    #6
     - agbear
     - 3:29 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
    I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

    As a teacher, yes. However, outside of the classroom, I feel parents are in charge and should be responsible for discipline.

    • 1 vote
    #7
     - Steve C.-305258
     - 3:30 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
    Yes. After all, it takes a village to raise a child.

    There are too many children raising themselves these days....I have no problem saying something when they are out of control.

      #8
       - terrisarlo
       - 3:42 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
      I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

      I agree that if the situation requires stepping in, then do it. For minor things, let the parent decide how to handle it.

      • 2 votes
      #9
       - YoungMom-1341083
       - 3:50 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
      Yes. After all, it takes a village to raise a child.

      By discipline, I mean as adults we should speak up and say something, not just ignore it.

      • 1 vote
      #10
       - Objective,empathetic,putyourselfnposition
       - 4:30 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
      Yes. After all, it takes a village to raise a child.

      Yes, and it depends. If it is safety related I would not hesitate, that includes children standing in the booth thank you...

        #11
         - NKAWTG
         - 7:24 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
        I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

        If someone spanked my child, I would be very very angry. Spanking someone else's 9 or 10 yr old child is abuse!

        • 3 votes
        #12
         - realitychk-2073667
         - 8:09 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
        I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

        i think it is okay to discipline someone elses child if you are around them alot,but if you're unknown to them then mind your own business.

        • 1 vote
        #13
         - alemesia
         - 8:13 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
        I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

        My house; my rules. Out in public, one should never criticize another's child. However, the evil eye does work wonders when needed.

        • 1 vote
        #14
         - sdswith5
         - 8:57 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
        I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

        if its a common sense situation i think it will okay otherwise mom and dad need to take care of the situation

          #15
           - america e.
           - 11:25 pm EDT on Mon Jul 26, 2010
          Yes. After all, it takes a village to raise a child.

          I corrected boy at produce market barehanded at sample tray of watermelon. He picked up & put down 2 pieces. Mom acted like I was molester

            #16
             - Carrie-2076914
             - 7:52 am EDT on Tue Jul 27, 2010
            Yes. After all, it takes a village to raise a child.

            some parents are so tuned out they may not even be aware that their kids are causing problems for others. In those cases I speak up.

              #17
               - dejavudu
               - 8:02 am EDT on Tue Jul 27, 2010
              Yes. After all, it takes a village to raise a child.

              I think it is okay to let a child know that a behavior is unacceptable, not necessarily to discipline.

              • 1 vote
              #18
               - Kim-2077011
               - 8:48 am EDT on Tue Jul 27, 2010
              No. Different parents have different styles; it's better to mind your own business.

              I don't want to have to disipline anyone else kid. That is why I did not have any of my own. Parents - take care of your own !

              • 1 vote
              #19
               - happily poor
               - 2:49 pm EDT on Tue Jul 27, 2010
              I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

              When other kids are at our house I let minor things slide...but if it's dangerous or mean, I intervene.

                #20
                 - lynlagro
                 - 10:19 am EDT on Wed Jul 28, 2010
                No. Different parents have different styles; it's better to mind your own business.

                It does take a village to raise a child, but before you discipline MY child, you're going to have to prove we're from the same village.

                • 2 votes
                #21
                 - slapout52
                 - 3:26 pm EDT on Wed Jul 28, 2010
                No. Different parents have different styles; it's better to mind your own business.

                NEVER lay your hand on someone else's kids, but DO let the parents know about any misbehavior so that they can discipline their own child.

                • 1 vote
                #22
                 - Ben-1268009
                 - 3:19 pm EDT on Fri Jul 30, 2010
                I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

                I think if you have a relationship with the family that would make it permittable that it is okay, not okay if you don't know them well.

                  #23
                   - mommie
                   - 4:11 pm EDT on Fri Jul 30, 2010
                  Yes. After all, it takes a village to raise a child.

                  I would discipline children that enter into my house and act unacceptable. Their mother can have rules in her house. I have rules in mine.

                    #24
                     - ljl87
                     - 3:29 pm EDT on Sun Aug 1, 2010
                    I'm not sure. It would depend on the situation.

                    If a child causes harm to himself or anyone else I will step in. Otherwise I believe in alerting the parents, if parents are not paying att

                      #25
                       - Maureen-2110378
                       - 1:24 pm EDT on Mon Aug 2, 2010
                      Jump to short comment page: 1 2

                      "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

                      37 comments, including:

                      I believe that a child should be discipline right when it happens, I've been fortunate to be able discipline other children in the presence of their parents, I get a thumbs up when I tell a child to not talk in a certain way or to teach them how to say "excuse me" when they walk in front of someo …

                      Show more
                      Explore related topics: discipline
                    • 27
                      Jan
                      2010
                      12:37pm, EST

                      Do you think spanking is an effective form of discipline?

                      Tantrums, whining, not listening, bedtime battles, power struggles. It’s enough to drive parents crazy. So why do kids misbehave? And is spanking an effective way to deal with it?

                      Results with 7 short comments
                      Total of 340 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

                      30.9%
                      Yes. When other options fail, spanking (when used safely and judiciously) can have a big impact.
                      105 votes
                      22.9%
                      No. Spanking only re-inforces negative behavior and doesn't teach children how problems can be solved through proper, positive communication.
                      78 votes
                      46.2%
                      Sometimes. When used in conjunction with appropriate verbal discipline, spanking can be a useful tool for parents.
                      157 votes
                      Display Comments:
                      Sometimes. When used in conjunction with appropriate verbal discipline, spanking can be a useful tool for parents.

                      Rarely. If used as a consequence of forbidden behavior when other punishment fails.

                        #26
                         - Sara-370701
                         - 4:28 pm EST on Wed Jan 27, 2010
                        No. Spanking only re-inforces negative behavior and doesn't teach children how problems can be solved through proper, positive communication.

                        Spanking is awful because you are inflicting violence to get someone to bend to your will it is abuse no matter what!!!!!

                          #27
                           - ajschultz45
                           - 8:00 pm EST on Wed Jan 27, 2010
                          Sometimes. When used in conjunction with appropriate verbal discipline, spanking can be a useful tool for parents.

                          There is a big difference between spanking and beating and some people are just not able to tell the difference.

                            #28
                             - jamib
                             - 9:47 pm EST on Wed Jan 27, 2010
                            Sometimes. When used in conjunction with appropriate verbal discipline, spanking can be a useful tool for parents.

                            RESPECT! ~TO and FROM the child. I taught it to a young man I mentored. As he displayed 'respect' he saw it come back in a happy Mom.

                              #29
                               - Bob-1588955
                               - 10:01 pm EST on Wed Jan 27, 2010
                              No. Spanking only re-inforces negative behavior and doesn't teach children how problems can be solved through proper, positive communication.

                              For the spankers out there, know that the only thing you are teaching your child is that it is ok to use physical force on another person.

                              • 1 vote
                              #30
                               - Cindy Royal
                               - 8:39 pm EST on Fri Jan 29, 2010
                              No. Spanking only re-inforces negative behavior and doesn't teach children how problems can be solved through proper, positive communication.

                              you cant teach a child to stop hitting or hurting someone when you are going to hit them.

                                #31
                                 - momof1-1604665
                                 - 11:21 am EST on Wed Feb 3, 2010
                                No. Spanking only re-inforces negative behavior and doesn't teach children how problems can be solved through proper, positive communication.

                                All it taught me was not to respect my parents...after all how could I respect two people who lost control? I have no relationship with the

                                  #32
                                   - Phoenix-910413
                                   - 12:02 pm EST on Wed Feb 3, 2010

                                  "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

                                  1 comment, including:

                                  ...oh hells yeah! Come over here and bend over my knee...

                                  Show more
                                  Explore related topics: spanking, discipline, parenting, showfront
                                • 4
                                  Jan
                                  2010
                                  12:17pm, EST

                                  Is it OK to discipline someone else's child?

                                  We've all been there. Someone else's child is acting up, being unsafe or acting inappropriately and we're faced with the dilemma? Do we say something or just bite our tongues?

                                  Results with 7 short comments
                                  Total of 544 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

                                  34.4%
                                  Yes. It's OK to say something, but leave the actual discipline up to his/her parent or guardian.
                                  187 votes
                                  7.2%
                                  No. Take it up with the parent. You shouldn't address the child directly.
                                  39 votes
                                  58.5%
                                  Maybe. It depends on how close the child's parent is. But if they're not nearby and safety is involved, you should definitely speak up.
                                  318 votes
                                  Display Comments:
                                  Yes. It's OK to say something, but leave the actual discipline up to his/her parent or guardian.

                                  It has become unreal how many parents let their kids run amok. When mine makes a scene we leave. It's only fair to others

                                    #33
                                     - sugarponies
                                     - 1:08 pm EST on Mon Jan 4, 2010
                                    Yes. It's OK to say something, but leave the actual discipline up to his/her parent or guardian.

                                    I guess it depends on more than 1 factor of safety. Our life group, whom we are close to, says that this is one of the best things we have

                                      #34
                                       - Jeff-236633
                                       - 1:33 pm EST on Mon Jan 4, 2010
                                      Yes. It's OK to say something, but leave the actual discipline up to his/her parent or guardian.

                                      A simple verbal warning is reasonable, if the child's behavior is inappropriate, dangerous, or beyond normal child playfulness.

                                        #35
                                         - JmetheSad
                                         - 2:57 pm EST on Mon Jan 4, 2010
                                        Maybe. It depends on how close the child's parent is. But if they're not nearby and safety is involved, you should definitely speak up.

                                        I wouldn't discipline someone's child but I'd take a steak knife away from them! If a child won't follow my rules, he/she gets to go home!

                                          #36
                                           - Alice-354401
                                           - 3:02 pm EST on Mon Jan 4, 2010
                                          Yes. It's OK to say something, but leave the actual discipline up to his/her parent or guardian.

                                          I appreciate adults guiding my kids toward good decisions if I am not there. An appropriate chat as an incident occurs makes a lesson stick

                                            #37
                                             - MomLearnsToo
                                             - 3:14 pm EST on Mon Jan 4, 2010
                                            Maybe. It depends on how close the child's parent is. But if they're not nearby and safety is involved, you should definitely speak up.

                                            If the child is about to suffer physical harm, yes.

                                              #38
                                               - Utah Soccer Mom
                                               - 3:45 pm EST on Mon Jan 4, 2010
                                              Yes. It's OK to say something, but leave the actual discipline up to his/her parent or guardian.

                                              Thats depends on the character of that particalar child.There is nothing wrong to show him/here the right/wrong things if u care.

                                                #39
                                                 - RICHARD MOTLHANKANE
                                                 - 8:48 am EST on Wed Jan 6, 2010

                                                "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

                                                2 comments, including:

                                                If my family were at a wedding and one of my children ahead of us in a buffet line was touching food, blocking the way for adults, or had their hair in a dish, please say something, I don't want to be embarrased.

                                                Show more
                                                Explore related topics: discipline, parenting, showfront

                                              Browse

                                              • showfront,
                                              • featured,
                                              • crib-notes,
                                              • parenting,
                                              • notes,
                                              • crib,
                                              • health,
                                              • cribnotes,
                                              • kids,
                                              • halloween,
                                              • holidays,
                                              • moms,
                                              • education,
                                              • teens,
                                              • pregnancy,
                                              • children,
                                              • toys,
                                              • entertainment,
                                              • breast-feeding,
                                              • mom,
                                              • babies,
                                              • facebook,
                                              • secrets,
                                              • school,
                                              • natalie-morales,
                                              • bullying,
                                              • discipline,
                                              • working-moms,
                                              • motherhood,
                                              • sex,
                                              • nutrition,
                                              • dads,
                                              • celebrity,
                                              • technology,
                                              • holiday,
                                              • baby
                                              Also

                                              Top TODAY.com headlines

                                              3155,10
                                              advertisement

                                              Rebecca Dube

                                              Rebecca Dube is a senior editor at TODAY.com and the TODAY Moms blog. She has one adorable son, a wicked Diet Coke habit and mountains of unwashed laundry.

                                              Rebecca Dube Blogroll

                                              • BabyCenter Momformation
                                              • Motherlode
                                              • Free Range Kids
                                              • Her Bad Mother
                                              • Let's Panic About Babies!
                                              • Blogess
                                              • Jillian Lauren
                                              • 18 Years to Life
                                              • Redneck Mommy
                                              • Dad Solo
                                              Get social!
                                              Do you like TODAY Moms? Check us out at facebook.com/todaymoms, and follow us at twitter.com/#!/todaymoms

                                              Archives

                                              • 2012
                                                • February (17)
                                                • January (65)
                                              • 2011
                                                • December (61)
                                                • November (75)
                                                • October (83)
                                                • September (81)
                                                • August (81)
                                                • July (79)
                                                • June (91)
                                                • May (90)
                                                • April (83)
                                                • March (94)
                                                • February (63)
                                                • January (84)
                                              • 2010
                                                • December (67)
                                                • November (102)
                                                • October (126)
                                                • September (113)
                                                • August (117)
                                                • July (43)
                                                • June (42)
                                                • May (60)
                                                • April (58)
                                                • March (59)
                                                • February (63)
                                                • January (67)
                                              • 2009
                                                • December (82)
                                                • November (87)
                                                • October (81)
                                                • September (5)
                                                • June (1)
                                                • May (1)

                                              Recent Posts

                                              • What to do when your 5-year-old announces he's in love (1)
                                              • Crib notes: Keeping up with the Duggars, with baby #19
                                              • Even David Beckham embarrasses his kids
                                              • Valentine's survey: What, and who, we want to do this V-Day (19)
                                              • Crib notes: Nursing moms to Facebook: Suck it (or, watch our babies suckle it)
                                              • Mom blogger Susan Niebur loses battle with cancer (2)
                                              • The French are better parents? Excusez-moi? (222)
                                              • Crib notes: I don't want to marry you, I just want to co-parent with you (1)

                                              Other blogs

                                              • allDAY
                                              • Animal Tracks
                                              • Bites
                                              • The Clicker
                                              • Digital Life
                                              • Hip2Save
                                              • Life Inc.
                                              • The Look
                                              • Scoop
                                              • TODAY Moms

                                              More on TODAY.com

                                              3155,8
                                              © 2012 msnbc.com
                                              • msnbc.com
                                              • About us
                                              • Contact
                                              • Help
                                              • Site map
                                              • Careers
                                              • Terms & Conditions
                                              • MSN Privacy
                                              • Legal
                                              • Advertise