• MSN
  • Hotmail
  • More
    • Autos
    • My MSN
    • Video
    • Careers & Jobs
    • Personals
    • Weather
    • Delish
    • Quotes
    • White Pages
    • Games
    • Real Estate
    • Wonderwall
    • Horoscopes
    • Shopping
    • Yellow Pages
    • Local Edition
    • Traffic
    • Feedback
    • Maps & Directions
    • Travel
    • Full MSN Index
  • Bing
  • msnbc.com sites & shows:
  • TODAY
  • Rock Center
  • Nightly News
  • Meet the Press
  • Dateline
  • Morning Joe
  • Hardball
  • Ed
  • Maddow
  • The Last Word
  • msnbc tv
  • People
  • Entertainment
  • Food
  • Health
  • Money
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Pets
  • Parenting
  • Style
  • KLG & Hoda
  • Blogs
    • allDAY
    • Animal Tracks
    • Bites
    • The Clicker
    • Digital Life
    • Hip2Save
    • Kathie Lee & Hoda
    • Life Inc.
    • The Look
    • Scoop
    • TODAY Entertainment
    • TODAY Health
    • TODAY Moms
    • TODAY Travel
  • More
    • Comics & Games
    • Concert Series
    • Good News!
    • Horoscope
    • Lotto
    • News
    • Photo Features
    • Relationships
    • The Royals
    • Tech
    • TODAY at 60
    • Weather
    • Weddings
  • Recommended: Help Natalie Morales with her boys' bedtime routines!
  • Recommended: My little Linus: In defense of security blankets
  • Recommended: Parent confession: Many skip booster seats for carpoolers
  • Recommended: Homeless dad's message of hope: 'Never give up'
Learn, share and discuss at TODAY Moms: parenting news and views from TODAY, top headlines and you. We're all in this together, so join the conversation.
  • ↓ About this blog
  • ↓ Archives
    • Icons Email E-mail updates
      You are subscribed.
      change this
      ()
      Loading Saving...
    • Icons Twitter Follow on Twitter
    • Icons Feed Subscribe to RSS
  • advertisement
    4
    Feb
    2010
    9:22am, EST

    Boy nearly suspensed over tiny toy gun: Was it reasonable?

    A 9-year-old New York boy faced the prospect of suspension after the principal at his school saw him playing with a LEGO policeman carrying a toy machine gun. Do you think the principal's actions were reasonable?

    Results with 93 short comments
    Total of 2,158 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

    5.3%
    Yes. The school rules were clear. No toy guns allowed.
    114 votes
    94.7%
    No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.
    2,044 votes
    Display Comments:
    No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

    This proves you can't legistlate common sense.

    • 2 votes
    #1
     - Cindy Carr
     - 9:44 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
    No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

    The principal was obviously not acting in the spirit of the meaning of the law. idiot. this child will probably never like school again

    • 4 votes
    #2
     - Real Life
     - 10:15 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
    Yes. The school rules were clear. No toy guns allowed.

    It's not the toy gun, but the idea of a real gun that rules are addressing. If parents want more gun flexibility, then change the rules.

    • 1 vote
    #3
     - Lawrence-565036
     - 10:19 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
    No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

    Common sense should prevail over any over ambitious rule.

    • 3 votes
    #4
     - C NJ Mom 1
     - 10:19 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
    No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

    Another example of brainless school administration. It seems that the toy is one unit. Therefore it cannot be described as a toy gun.

    • 3 votes
    #5
     - Steven B
     - 10:21 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
    Yes. The school rules were clear. No toy guns allowed.

    and Please change the name of your website to "today's Parents"; let's end sexism and the idea that moms are responsible for parenting.

    • 2 votes
    #6
     - ms. hoo
     - 10:24 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
    No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

    It's a shame people with such an alarming lack of perspective are teaching our kids.

    • 2 votes
    #7
     - Marshall in PA
     - 10:32 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
    No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

    Bring back common sense and compassion not fear to dictate our judgements. Cynical views of our beloved America is becoming reality.

    • 2 votes
    #8
     - John Smith12345
     - 10:34 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
    No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

    Obviously the educators are uneducated.

      #9
       - mikePietsch
       - 10:47 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
      No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

      It is idiotic, as are most policies in this day and age.

      • 2 votes
      #10
       - coduto
       - 10:54 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
      No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

      It was toy of a police officer, they carry guns. Guns are important in law enforcement and protection we shouldn't hide that fact from kids

      • 2 votes
      #11
       - jeninholland02
       - 11:06 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
      No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

      'No tolerance' has become no thought, no sense, no compassion for witless school administrators.

      • 3 votes
      #12
       - Pacific NW Mark
       - 11:09 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
      No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

      It seems that common sense has become a rare commodity these days - especially in school administrators and teachers.

      • 3 votes
      #13
       - SkyWriter3
       - 11:10 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
      Yes. The school rules were clear. No toy guns allowed.

      Where do they draw the line, 3" 4" 6" real gun size? It is too difficult to put arbitrary limits on toy sizes. Zero means 0, deal with it!

      • 2 votes
      #14
       - Tomo101
       - 11:10 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
      No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

      This is a small child with a 2" gun. Get real to all schools

      • 1 vote
      #15
       - Lori Johns
       - 11:14 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
      No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

      WTF? It is a lego toy. How could anyone make out what it was if it is less than 2"? I think the teacher had something up her butt that day

      • 2 votes
      #16
       - reggie7777
       - 11:26 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
      No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

      We're doomed as a country

      • 2 votes
      #17
       - mattgjetfreak
       - 11:27 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
      No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

      The intent was not malicious. It seems over the top given the content of the article.

        #18
         - tastingblue-1459640
         - 11:28 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
        No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

        Stupid! Nobody in their right mind would be threatened by such a "gun". It couldn't possibly do any harm. What happened to common sense?

        • 2 votes
        #19
         - DL-360205
         - 11:30 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
        Yes. The school rules were clear. No toy guns allowed.

        This extreme demonstrates how silly it is when we try to legislate safety in such manor. No mater the common sense-it is the rule.

          #20
           - Lysistrata
           - 11:31 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
          No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

          I hope that principal gets a speeding ticket for 1mph over the speed limit and then his insurance goes up for 5 years. That'll learn him!

            #21
             - Amazedbythenews
             - 11:39 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
            No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

            Common sense doesn't seem to exist anymore.

            • 1 vote
            #22
             - Sunbeam
             - 11:43 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
            No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

            Yes the school says no toy guns, but a 2 inch LEGO gun? Give me a break! I am sick to death of folks who only see in black and white!!!!!

              #23
               - Turquoise1957
               - 11:43 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
              No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

              A formal apology needs to be issued to this child, and the people responsible should receive a common sense lesson.

              • 1 vote
              #24
               - Brokinarrow
               - 11:52 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
              No. I think it's ridiculous. The LEGO gun was barely 2 inches in size.

              Idiots. They should have called his parents explaining the rule, not torment this kid. Worry about the education system which stinks now.

              • 1 vote
              #25
               - war_manelli
               - 11:53 am EST on Thu Feb 4, 2010
              Jump to short comment page: 1 2 3 4

              "Like" TODAY Moms on Facebook, and follow us @TodayMoms

              104 comments, including:

              The principal should simply be fired. She obviously is so lacking in cognitive abilities that she is unable to discern a difference between a tiny toy gun and a real one or a full-sized replica. Someone that dumb should never be put in charge of educating our children.

              Show more
              Explore related topics: lego-gun, showfront, school-suspension, kids-and-guns

            Browse

            • showfront,
            • featured,
            • crib-notes,
            • parenting,
            • notes,
            • crib,
            • health,
            • cribnotes,
            • kids,
            • halloween,
            • holidays,
            • moms,
            • education,
            • teens,
            • pregnancy,
            • children,
            • toys,
            • entertainment,
            • breast-feeding,
            • mom,
            • babies,
            • facebook,
            • secrets,
            • school,
            • natalie-morales,
            • bullying,
            • discipline,
            • working-moms,
            • motherhood,
            • sex,
            • nutrition,
            • dads,
            • celebrity,
            • technology,
            • holiday,
            • baby
            Also

            Top TODAY.com headlines

            3155,10
            advertisement

            Archives

            • 2012
              • February (17)
              • January (65)
            • 2011
              • December (61)
              • November (75)
              • October (83)
              • September (81)
              • August (81)
              • July (79)
              • June (91)
              • May (90)
              • April (83)
              • March (94)
              • February (63)
              • January (84)
            • 2010
              • December (67)
              • November (102)
              • October (126)
              • September (113)
              • August (117)
              • July (43)
              • June (42)
              • May (60)
              • April (58)
              • March (59)
              • February (63)
              • January (67)
            • 2009
              • December (82)
              • November (87)
              • October (81)
              • September (5)
              • June (1)
              • May (1)

            Recent Posts

            • What to do when your 5-year-old announces he's in love (1)
            • Crib notes: Keeping up with the Duggars, with baby #19
            • Even David Beckham embarrasses his kids
            • Valentine's survey: What, and who, we want to do this V-Day (19)
            • Crib notes: Nursing moms to Facebook: Suck it (or, watch our babies suckle it)
            • Mom blogger Susan Niebur loses battle with cancer (2)
            • The French are better parents? Excusez-moi? (222)
            • Crib notes: I don't want to marry you, I just want to co-parent with you (1)

            Other blogs

            • allDAY
            • Animal Tracks
            • Bites
            • The Clicker
            • Digital Life
            • Hip2Save
            • Life Inc.
            • The Look
            • Scoop
            • TODAY Moms

            More on TODAY.com

            3155,8
            © 2012 msnbc.com
            • msnbc.com
            • About us
            • Contact
            • Help
            • Site map
            • Careers
            • Terms & Conditions
            • MSN Privacy
            • Legal
            • Advertise